Who will go down as a better fighter CARL FROCH OR CHAD DAWSON

[slimshandy69]

Chad Dawson was ranked above Floyd Gayweather some years back by a small minority, and was P4P 2.

But has lost to Pascal whom a poor froch beat by at least 4 rounds.

Who at the end of their careers will be ranked in higher regard?

[bojangles1987]

Chad Dawson was never p4p #2.

I'd say they are close right now. Froch is still going strong where Dawson is likely done or close to done, so unless Froch never picks up a relevant win again he'll have the better career.

[Alec900]

I don't give a flying duck

[Da Machine]

Can't be a serious question.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I gotta go with froch.......

Dawson has

Adamek: A+ prime adamek, great win
Johnson: C johnson got robbed
Johnson2: B good win but johnson on the downhill slide
Tarver 1,2: B good name but not prime tarver
hopkins 1,2: A won lineal championship, hopkins is tough out for anyone

Froch
Taylor
pascal
abraham
dirrel
bute
kessler


Froch beat more prime fighters, dawson beat a great adamek, but johnson, tarver and hopkins had all past prime........

plus froch doesnt have any bad losses like dawson does... losing to kessler in a war in denmark and to andre ward and never getting blown out and ko'd in 90 seconds...

i gotta go with froch
dawson never had a huge signature dominant performance like froch had with bute

[IronDanHamza]

Chad Dawson was never P4P #2 or ranked above Floyd.

And Froch will go down as the greater fighter in my eyes. Without question.

[GeneralZod]

Chad Dawson was ranked above Floyd Gayweather some years back by a small minority, and was P4P 2.

But has lost to Pascal whom a poor froch beat by at least 4 rounds.

Who at the end of their careers will be ranked in higher regard?

I stopped right there. When we're still doing that "haha i changed part of your name to gay" stuff, it's time to stop trying.

[KickAzz]

Froch cherrypicker is gay though

[Guest]

Joke thread, surely? Froch by far.

[slimshandy69]

Dawson was claimed to be P4P number 1 by small minority and a number of people had him "schooling" a ATG calzaghe.

A lot of people denying the past here.

So not a silly question.