Who has had (or will have) more than one truly meaningful win this year?

[ИATAS]

Hopkins over Cloud/Murat gets my vote.

/Thread

[Bushbaby]

Garcia's win over Lucas is greater than Rigo's over Donaire imo.

[ИATAS]

Garcia's win over Lucas is greater than Rigo's over Donaire imo.

Donaire was top five p4p and multiple weight class champion. Matthysse, while a good fighter, was never ranked top ten.

[_original_]

Garcia's win over Lucas is greater than Rigo's over Donaire imo.

No way!

Lucas Matthysse wasn't a top 5 P4P fighter or had such a resume. Plus, Rigo handled Donaire with relative ease, the Garcia/Matthysse fight was quite close.

[RiC-DiC]

Garcia's win over Lucas is greater than Rigo's over Donaire imo.

I agree. Danny was the underdog, didn't backpedal for 11 rounds and didn't get knocked down; he knocked down the beast who was supposed to destroy Danny.

[ИATAS]

I agree. Danny was the underdog, didn't backpedal for 11 rounds and didn't get knocked down; he knocked down the beast who was supposed to destroy Danny.

Rigo was the underdog too. He also didn't clinch and low blow 1000 times.

[-PBP-]

Estrada too. Beat Viloria and Melindo with likely one more title defense this year.

[Public_Enemy]

It's Floyd. Lucas had a shot but he lost. Canelo had a shot but he lost. Rigo has the best single win but no other fights. It's hard to make a legitimate argument for anyone but Floyd. Danny is probably second. Rigo 3rd.

[puga]

The fact is, Guererro and Canelo were both in the Top 10 P4P (The Ring)

Canelo was the event of the year.

These are the kind of things they look at.

Floyd's going to win it. I'd be shocked if he doesn't.

yeah but who really thought or could justify them being on the list was right?..no one could .. they were the biggest joke of fighters to ever be on that list period...

rigo or garcia should be the obvious choice here but i do think they're going to give it to floyd..

[IronDanHamza]

yeah but who really thought or could justify them being on the list was right?..no one could .. they were the biggest joke of fighters to ever be on that list period...

rigo or garcia should be the obvious choice here but i do think they're going to give it to floyd..

I can understand where you're coming from but I'm just looking at it from the point of view of them.