Who has had (or will have) more than one truly meaningful win this year?

[DoktorSleepless]

I can't really think of anyone. It's going to be hard picking fighter of the year again.

[Counter Troll]

Rigondeaux UD12 Donaire is the most quality win of the year thus far.

Multiple wins? Has to be Mayweather.

[bojangles1987]

Rigo over Donaire is better than any two wins anyone has. He's still the front runner.

[Ivansmamma]

Bradley probably.

[-PBP-]

Rigondeaux over Donaire/December fight

Garcia over Judah/Matthysse

Floyd over Guerrero/Canelo


Bradley can possibly get in the mix with a W over Marquez

Jhonny Gonzalez can get considered if he beats Mares again

[IronDanHamza]

Mayweather is going to win Fighter of The Year this year.

Seems obvious.

[DoktorSleepless]

Guerrero was always crap. I don't think it's a meaningful win. I'll give him credit for Canelo.

Ruslan Provodnikov was barely rated before he fought Bradly. I wouldn't call it meaningful.

Garcia's win over Judah isn't something to get excited about either. Judah was top 10, but I hesitate to call it a meaninfull win.

I think Garcia, Gonzales, and Rigo, and Stevenson have the best single wins this year, but I'd hate someone getting FOY based on a single win. That's someone having a great day, not a great year.

[IronDanHamza]

Guerrero was always crap. I don't think it's a meaningful win. I'll give him credit for Canelo.

Ruslan Provodnikov was barely rated before he fought Bradly. I wouldn't call it meaningful.

Garcia's win over Judah isn't something to get excited about either. Judah was top 10, but I hesitate to call it a meaninfull win.

I think Garcia, Gonzales, and Rigo, and Stevenson have the best single wins this year, but I'd hate someone getting FOY based on a single win. That's someone having a great day, not a great year.

The fact is, Guererro and Canelo were both in the Top 10 P4P (The Ring)

Canelo was the event of the year.

These are the kind of things they look at.

Floyd's going to win it. I'd be shocked if he doesn't.

[gauze]

if donaire can win it by fighting 4 meh-ish guys, i dont see why golovkin shouldnt be able to. not that i agree with it, but just sayin!

[gmc_rfc_06]

FOTY is Mayweather, virtually a lock IMO.