Why can't (some) posters here distinguish a past prime fighter and a "shot" fighter?

[FrankieClutch]

There's a big difference. Learn it.

[FrankieClutch]

Example:

The DLH that fought Mayweather was past-prime.
The DLH that fought Pac-man was shot.

Agree?

[Idksab]

I don't the think the Oscar that fought Pac was shot per se, he was just severely dehydrated.

[FrankieClutch]

I don't the think the Oscar that fought Pac was shot per se, he was just severely dehydrated.

He was definitely dehydrated, but I say he was shot because he looked horrid against Steve Forbes

[puga]

oscar that floyd fought = past prime

oscar that manny fought = past prime and dehydrated

but styles make fights , prime for prime , i think pac would've done hell of a lot better than floyd.....just like he did vs hatton , shane , and cotto...

[FrankieClutch]

oscar that floyd fought = past prime

oscar that manny fought = past prime and dehydrated

but styles make fights , prime for prime , i think pac would've done hell of a lot better than floyd.....just like he did vs hatton , shane , and cotto...

I agree, but I honestly believe that Oscar in his prime beats Pac and Floyd. That's a whole different convo though lol

[Jc8804]

Cause they don know ish about boxing

[boxer2k5]

Example:

The DLH that fought Mayweather was past-prime.
The DLH that fought Pac-man was shot.

Agree?

most def agreed.

[boxer2k5]

oscar that floyd fought = past prime

oscar that manny fought = past prime and dehydrated

but styles make fights , prime for prime , i think pac would've done hell of a lot better than floyd.....just like he did vs hatton , shane , and cotto...

prime Oscar is bigger stronger and faster than marquez with better footwork. He knocks prime many who IMO is still 130-135 out cold. Prime Oscar vs prime Floyd I feel Oscar wins more than 3(which I gave him in his fight) but still loses. Prime Floyd is also 130-135. Oscar prime was 135-147. so Oscar beats many at 135 badly. and loses a close decision to Floyd at lightweight. styles make fights

[SlySlickSmooth]

Example:

The DLH that fought Mayweather was past-prime.
The DLH that fought Pac-man was shot.

Agree?

Yes I do.


Some never will.