I see some posters saying that one win on a fighters resume is better then anothers

[Larry the boss]

Entire resume,can this be true? Fraziers win over Ali is better then any win Ali had..does Frazier rank higher? Juans win over Manny is better then anything on Mannys resume,does he rank higher?Oscars win over Whitaker is a better win then any win on Whitakers resume,does he rank higher?

[Weebler I]

Some people put Rigondeaux on their PFP list solely for beating Donaire. It's just how some people see it.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Oh hey look, Larry is back.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[The Big Dunn]

Entire resume,can this be true? Fraziers win over Ali is better then any win Ali had..does Frazier rank higher? Juans win over Manny is better then anything on Mannys resume,does he rank higher?Oscars win over Whitaker is a better win then any win on Whitakers resume,does he rank higher?

Larryx if you are a poster who is arguing manny is the best-than this arguement is ok. In any other cirumstance its pure bull****.

[IronDanHamza]

It doesn't mean anything.

Ruben Carter's win over Emile Griffith is better and more impressive than any win on Mayweather, Hopkins, Roy Jones, Pacquaio, Holyfield etc etc etc

What does that mean? Nothing.

I would also say in response to your opening post that Whitakers wins over Chavez and Nelson are much better than Oscar's win over Whitaker.

[Larry the boss]

Larryx if you are a poster who is arguing manny is the best-than this arguement is ok. In any other cirumstance its pure bull****.

I hear some of them say Mannys win over Barerra is better then anything on Floyds resume so he ranks higher,ok So does Torrecampo rank higher then Manny? does Juan rank higher then Manny? Does Bradley now rank higher then Manny?because their wins over Manny is better then anything on Mannys resume

[hhs661]

Larryx if you are a poster who is arguing manny is the best-than this arguement is ok. In any other cirumstance its pure bull****.

One must not forget that his wins are even better regardless if he faces someone off a loss or even after a certain fighter beats them first

[Larry the boss]

So i guess Max Smelling ranks higher then any current fighter for his win over Joe Louis

[-PBP-]

The argument works in some cases. With Buster Douglas and others we have the benefit of hindsight and we can see that those fighters were just one shot wonders.

If your comparing two ATG's, both with pretty even resumes and pretty even skill wise I think its perfectly legit.

In an argument between Roy Jones vs. Bernard Hopkins you can say "Roy's win over a prime James Toney is better than anything on Hopkins resume"

In an argument between Guillermo Rigondeaux and Abner Mares you can say "Rigo's win over Donaire is better than anything on Mares' resume"

In an argument between Larry Holmes vs. Buster Douglas that argument won't work.

You just have to use common sense.

[fabie]

**then** **than**