I see some posters saying that one win on a fighters resume is better then anothers

[The Big Dunn]

I hear some of them say Mannys win over Barerra is better then anything on Floyds resume so he ranks higher,ok So does Torrecampo rank higher then Manny? does Juan rank higher then Manny? Does Bradley now rank higher then Manny?because their wins over Manny is better then anything on Mannys resume

I think you know the deal with some Manny fans. The same posters that argue this will tell you Margs was better than Baldo yet Baldo's win over Zab was (at the time) better than any Marg win.

See this theory only works when trying to make a case for Manny ahead of floyd, JMM, RJJ, Bhop. Attepmting to apply it in any other circumstance or applying it TO Manny is invalid.

So no, If you beat Manny it doesn't make you better than him. It means you used ped's, or stepped on his foot, or he was weak from blood being drawn. Understand?

[Black Barty]

Some people put Rigondeaux on their PFP list solely for beating Donaire. It's just how some people see it.

I'm not a huge Rigo fan, but I'm ok with him being on the P4P list for beating Donaire. Donaire was a top 5 (arguably top 3) P4P guy before their fight. I wouldn't say that that one win trumps the entire resume of Mares, Wlad, Froch etc, but P4P lists aren't based solely on resume. If they were, Roy Jones would still be on them (he hasn't officially retired yet, has he?). P4P is a combination of resume and current ability, and if you can beat a guy like Donaire, your current ability is good enough for you to be on the list, even if you have no other great wins.