Was Cotto a Good Win for Trout?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Was Cotto a "shot fighter" vs Trout or just Mayweather?

Was reading my post too challenging for you?

[boliodogs]

It seemed like many on here gave Mayweather credit for a good win but of course some did not. It's always like that.You are never going to see all of boxing scene agreeing on anything. Trout fought Cotto shortly after Mayweather fought Cotto.He beat Cotto by almost the same one sided scorecards as Mayweather beat Cotto. I think the Cotto win was just as good a win for Trout as it was for Mayweather. Mayweather gets an edge because he is a welterweight beating the slightly bigger Cotto while Trout is a bigger man than Cotto.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Did Cotto ever get a top level win early in his career? Remind me of who it was he beat?

Your such a tool for mayweather but its ok, i will play along,,,

maybe you should research some cotto info if you dont know who he beat...

as a youngster he beat

Undefeated maussa who went on to win a belt
undefeated kelson pinto who was a amateur rival of cotto
Sosa,, after sosa went 12 with your boy floyd, cotto stomped him in 4
Corley after he went 12 vs floyd and zab-- cotto stopped him in 5
undefeated Torres who went on to win a belt
undefeated Pauli who went on to win some belts,,,

that was when cotto was young and at 140.......

who had trout beaten,,, delvin and canelo's brother,,,,

a shot cotto is better than anyone on trout's resume,,,
a shot cotto is not better than anyone on floyd's

do you understand now,,,, probably not since you come off as a blind idiot that cant comprehend the simplest of rationales,,,

If you cant see the difference between floyd and trout,,, and where they are at in their careers,, then you are honestly,, just ******

[bojangles1987]

Yes. He was an unknown underdog that some considered a tuneup.

[bojangles1987]

What's up with all the whiny Floyd fanboy threads recently?

Mayweather has, as he likes to remind everyone, been on top for years. Why would you compare his opposition to a relative newcomer like Trout?

Larry's back.

[itsafight]

Oh look it's gay boy with his pink font and Nicki Minaj gifs. Your boyfriend Cotto got humiliated. Lost 10 rounds out of 12 118-110 Trout. Worse beating than Mayweather.

[BafanaBafana]

Just asking cause according to many here at Boxingscene the Cotto that Floyd fought months earlier was shot and not considered a "good" win but the Cotto Trout fought later that same year is considered a "great" win?? So how does Cotto go from shot to not shot to not a "good" win to a "great" win? Anybody care to explain boxingscene logic to a new member of the forum?

It was a good win for Trout because he was relatively unknown and a big underdog going in (I knew he would win though). Cotto was one of Mayweather's best career wins up there with DLH and Corrales in my opinion, but still just a good (not great) win in the end.

[Imatroll]

wasn't cotto undefeated when he fought mayweather doe