This Site's P4P List (!)

[LacedUp]

Why do you not include heavyweights?

For a couple of reasons, mainly because the point of p4p is to determine who's the best fighter outside of the heavyweights.

Also because skillwise, speed etc, it's unjust to heavies to compare them imo.

[Hop]

Would love to see your list, Horseman. Who cares whose feathers are ruffled by it? I have plenty of boxing opinions that do the same.

[Public_Enemy]

1. Mayweather
2. *Ward- needs to get in the ring soon.
3. JMM
4. Rigo
5. Mares
6. Froch
7. Manny
8. Sergio
9. Wlad
10. Bradley

Honorable Mention: Canelo, Roman Gonzales, Estrada, Mikey Garcia, Donaire, Matthysse

[Hop]

Nice to see literally everybody recognizing the talents of Abner Mares, which surprises me a little (many such lists don't include him). Props, fells (short for "fellows").

Also, I need to educate myself on Roman Gonzales.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

broner and canelo have no business on a top 10 p4p list

[Hop]

broner and canelo have no business on a top 10 p4p list

What happened to the "Ewing" part of your screen name? Did he fall out of favor? LOL

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

What happened to the "Ewing" part of your screen name? Did he fall out of favor? LOL

doesnt fit. they keep things trim around here

[LacedUp]

broner and canelo have no business on a top 10 p4p list

Why not? Taking away the hate for both guys, they are champions in multiple weight classes, and have both faced top guys in their division.

Compare that to someone like Bradley who is frequently on many people's lists despite having a career best win over Devon Alexander who quit, and Junior witter of all people. Getting credit for robbing Pacman and Ruslan now?

[Hop]

doesnt fit. they keep things trim around here

Ah ... (the least exciting of the three anyway, IMO)

[Weebler I]

I much prefer boxingscene's pfp list to OP's pfp list. It's a bit rich that you would it call it nutty OP.