Rate my top 5 modern Greats.

[The Big Dunn]

So you're a racist.

Are you a black supremacist from the Nation of Islam? A follower of Farrakhan?

geez freedom. really?

floyd, roy, bhop, pea, toney of just the 5.

of the moder era: floyd, roy, manny, bhop, ricardo lopez,

[The Hammer]

You are insane for a having a guy like Calzaghe on the list over Mayweather. What has Calzaghe done that trumps what Mayweather have done? Do you seriously Think Zags resume is better than Floyds?

Exactly what do you mean by "a guy like Calzaghe"

I'm not saying Joe should be rated higher than Floyd, I was just suggesting other people that could be in a non-racist, non-nationalist top five.

That being said, Floyd isn't so great. He's has never beaten a prime world-class fighter from his own weight division.

He's cherry-picked good but old (Oscar, Hernandez, Mosley) smaller (Hatton, JMM) and mediocre/flawed (Ortiz) opponents. Now he's fighting a pre-prime kid at a catch weight.

[AztecWanker]

Lmaoooooo!!!! Its not my fault the greatest just HAPPEN to be black kid.

[The Hammer]

Lmaoooooo!!!! Its not my fault the greatest just HAPPEN to be black kid.

And American too, right?

James "Belly's Out" Toney who twice was caught cheating with steroids is not greater than Lennox Lewis.

[Kagami Taiga]

So you're a racist.

Are you a black supremacist from the Nation of Islam? A follower of Farrakhan?

just because someone doesnt agree with u, doesnt make them a racist. u need to stop that, ud be a much better poster and person for it.

[RubenSonny]

all belong there but if u are gonna include pernell then wheres lewis and holyfield?

It makes no sense to single Whitaker out he is the greatest fighter on the list and so far ahead of Lewis.

[Kagami Taiga]

It makes no sense to single Whitaker out he is the greatest fighter on the list and so far ahead of Lewis.

I agree I singled him out jot because of his greatness but because that expands the era.

[8thSamurai]

Nice list. Holyfield is greater than Toney tho.........Whitaker, Jones, Mayweather Hopkins, Pacquiao, Holyfield, Mike McCallum, James Toney, azumah nelson

[The Hammer]

just because someone doesnt agree with u, doesnt make them a racist. u need to stop that, ud be a much better poster and person for it.

It had nothing to do with his not agreeing.

He picked out the two white boxers, bolded their names, and then posted

What does that tell us about him?

THINK.

If someone made a list of the five smartest modern men (all white and American) and someone answered naming five men: two black, two Hispanic, and one white. Then the guy who made the original list of five smartest men bolded the two black names and posted the LOL three times. Would that be racist?

[RubenSonny]

Marco Antonio Barrera
Manny Pacquiao
Wladimir Klitschko
Joe Calzaghe
Lennox Lewis

I'd rate those five ahead of James "Belly's Out" Toney, who was twice caught cheating with steroids. And how many times has Roid Jones been KOed?

Just once more than Wladimir Klitschko