Rate my top 5 modern Greats.

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • AztecWanker
    Banned
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Aug 2008
    • 5331
    • 401
    • 505
    • 6,208

    #1

    Rate my top 5 modern Greats.

    1. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Say what you say about this man, but he might be the greatest fighter of our generation. Started at JLW and won titles there and in 4 other weight classes, maintaining a perfect record. Wins over P4P Puncher Diego Corrales, body snatcher Jose Luis Castillo and rugged Ricky Hatton of the UK are his biggest wins. Lack of risks career-wise will be his only blemish.

    2. Bernard Hopkins - Bernard Hopkins is a genius in the ring, plain and simple. He is to boxing what Prince is to pop music or what Fyodor Dostoevsky is to literature. There is no denying this man's talent and legacy. 20 defenses of the Middleweight title, then at age 41, skipped a weight class and fought Light Heavyweight King Antonio Tarver, who was coming off two excellent wins over Roy Jones Jr., giving him a thorough boxing lesson. He followed it up with a win over future hall of famer Winky Wright, then dropped a controversial split decision to Super Middleweight Joe Calzaghe. Bernard defied Father Time once again and schooled the young lion, Middleweight Champion Kelly Pavlik. 'Nard is an ATG without a doubt.


    3. James Toney - The most complete fighter IMO. He was an underrated puncher, hands so fast, he'd make Calzaghe blush. Great defense and a granite chin (only down 3 times in 70+ fights). He started his career at Middleweight, then moved up to Super Middleweight where he showed sensational skills. Also won titles at Cruserweight and Heavyweight where he tested positive for steroids. Other than the steroid mess at HW, his only flaw was his lack of discipline. Had he been more dedicated to his training, he probably would have been an undefeated, top 10 P4P all-time-great fighter.


    4. Roy Jones Jr. - Superman himself. The P4P King of the 90's. He would make title fights look like sparring sessions. Ruled the Middleweight, Super Middleweight, Light Heavyweight divisions. In 2003, he shocked the sports world when he made the jump to Heavyweight and won the title from John Ruiz. An exciting, unorthodox style with blinding handspeed made me a fan of his. Great fighter.

    5. Pernell Whitaker - I am a person that loves and appreciates defense and there wasn't a boxer on Earth that came close to "Sweet Pea" defensively. He would school his opponents with awesome upper-body and head movement and slick combinations. Will go down in history as the first man to defeat Julio Cesar Chavez, although as we all know, he got a bogus Draw instead of a Unanimous Decision that he deserved.
  • low_Bo
    Banned
    Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
    • Jan 2006
    • 789
    • 47
    • 2
    • 956

    #2
    Originally posted by Aztec Wanker
    1. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Say what you say about this man, but he might be the greatest fighter of our generation. Started at JLW and won titles there and in 4 other weight classes, maintaining a perfect record. Wins over P4P Puncher Diego Corrales, body snatcher Jose Luis Castillo and rugged Ricky Hatton of the UK are his biggest wins. Lack of risks career-wise will be his only blemish.

    2. Bernard Hopkins - Bernard Hopkins is a genius in the ring, plain and simple. He is to boxing what Prince is to pop music or what Fyodor Dostoevsky is to literature. There is no denying this man's talent and legacy. 20 defenses of the Middleweight title, then at age 41, skipped a weight class and fought Light Heavyweight King Antonio Tarver, who was coming off two excellent wins over Roy Jones Jr., giving him a thorough boxing lesson. He followed it up with a win over future hall of famer Winky Wright, then dropped a controversial split decision to Super Middleweight Joe Calzaghe. Bernard defied Father Time once again and schooled the young lion, Middleweight Champion Kelly Pavlik. 'Nard is an ATG without a doubt.


    3. James Toney - The most complete fighter IMO. He was an underrated puncher, hands so fast, he'd make Calzaghe blush. Great defense and a granite chin (only down 3 times in 70+ fights). He started his career at Middleweight, then moved up to Super Middleweight where he showed sensational skills. Also won titles at Cruserweight and Heavyweight where he tested positive for steroids. Other than the steroid mess at HW, his only flaw was his lack of discipline. Had he been more dedicated to his training, he probably would have been an undefeated, top 10 P4P all-time-great fighter.


    4. Roy Jones Jr. - Superman himself. The P4P King of the 90's. He would make title fights look like sparring sessions. Ruled the Middleweight, Super Middleweight, Light Heavyweight divisions. In 2003, he shocked the sports world when he made the jump to Heavyweight and won the title from John Ruiz. An exciting, unorthodox style with blinding handspeed made me a fan of his. Great fighter.

    5. Pernell Whitaker - I am a person that loves and appreciates defense and there wasn't a boxer on Earth that came close to "Sweet Pea" defensively. He would school his opponents with awesome upper-body and head movement and slick combinations. Will go down in history as the first man to defeat Julio Cesar Chavez, although as we all know, he got a bogus Draw instead of a Unanimous Decision that he deserved.
    Wow, this list is ****. I didn't even bother reading why you chose who you did.

    Comment

    • WARQUEZ
      World Class™
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Sep 2011
      • 4275
      • 296
      • 213
      • 12,259

      #3
      You forgot to add Rid**** Bowe, Paul Williams, Shane Mosley, Zab Judah, and Winky Wright.

      Make it a top 10 brother.

      Comment

      • PeterinMI
        Interim Champion
        Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
        • Nov 2007
        • 658
        • 31
        • 88
        • 7,427

        #4
        I like your list. I also like that it is not all about "excitement" but instead really talks about boxing. I would rank Sweet Pea above Toney but Toney is something special. I often forget how great both he and RJJ were because they stuck around far too long and in Toney's case did not have the discipline.

        I think without the Coke and if he had the discipline out of the ring of Mayweather Sweet Pea would be Top 5 of all time.



        Originally posted by Aztec Wanker
        1. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Say what you say about this man, but he might be the greatest fighter of our generation. Started at JLW and won titles there and in 4 other weight classes, maintaining a perfect record. Wins over P4P Puncher Diego Corrales, body snatcher Jose Luis Castillo and rugged Ricky Hatton of the UK are his biggest wins. Lack of risks career-wise will be his only blemish.

        2. Bernard Hopkins - Bernard Hopkins is a genius in the ring, plain and simple. He is to boxing what Prince is to pop music or what Fyodor Dostoevsky is to literature. There is no denying this man's talent and legacy. 20 defenses of the Middleweight title, then at age 41, skipped a weight class and fought Light Heavyweight King Antonio Tarver, who was coming off two excellent wins over Roy Jones Jr., giving him a thorough boxing lesson. He followed it up with a win over future hall of famer Winky Wright, then dropped a controversial split decision to Super Middleweight Joe Calzaghe. Bernard defied Father Time once again and schooled the young lion, Middleweight Champion Kelly Pavlik. 'Nard is an ATG without a doubt.


        3. James Toney - The most complete fighter IMO. He was an underrated puncher, hands so fast, he'd make Calzaghe blush. Great defense and a granite chin (only down 3 times in 70+ fights). He started his career at Middleweight, then moved up to Super Middleweight where he showed sensational skills. Also won titles at Cruserweight and Heavyweight where he tested positive for steroids. Other than the steroid mess at HW, his only flaw was his lack of discipline. Had he been more dedicated to his training, he probably would have been an undefeated, top 10 P4P all-time-great fighter.


        4. Roy Jones Jr. - Superman himself. The P4P King of the 90's. He would make title fights look like sparring sessions. Ruled the Middleweight, Super Middleweight, Light Heavyweight divisions. In 2003, he shocked the sports world when he made the jump to Heavyweight and won the title from John Ruiz. An exciting, unorthodox style with blinding handspeed made me a fan of his. Great fighter.

        5. Pernell Whitaker - I am a person that loves and appreciates defense and there wasn't a boxer on Earth that came close to "Sweet Pea" defensively. He would school his opponents with awesome upper-body and head movement and slick combinations. Will go down in history as the first man to defeat Julio Cesar Chavez, although as we all know, he got a bogus Draw instead of a Unanimous Decision that he deserved.

        Comment

        • 4Corners
          Nothing But Sunshine
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Jul 2011
          • 14441
          • 485
          • 83
          • 25,167

          #5
          Mayweather, Hopkins, Whitaker, Pacquiao, and Jones.

          Comment

          • Kagami Taiga
            Generation of Miracles
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Mar 2010
            • 19078
            • 703
            • 228
            • 40,183

            #6
            all belong there but if u are gonna include pernell then wheres lewis and holyfield?

            Comment

            • HarvardBlue
              Undisputed Champion
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Nov 2011
              • 6762
              • 224
              • 128
              • 41,455

              #7
              If I used your list this is the order I would put them in.
              1. Mayweather
              2. Whitaker
              3. Jones Jr
              4. Hopkins
              5. Toney
              The only reason I put Mayweather ahead of Whitaker (I'm a die hard Whitaker fan) is Mayweather's ability to figure out his opponents. Whitaker had better defense, and was busier, but their accuracy was about the same. My favorite Whitaker fight was against Buddy McGirt. That fight was damn near child abuse.

              Comment

              • Whigged
                Amateur
                • Dec 2005
                • 18
                • 3
                • 0
                • 6,248

                #8
                Definitely need a top 10 list bro. But off to a good start.

                Comment

                • AztecWanker
                  Banned
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Aug 2008
                  • 5331
                  • 401
                  • 505
                  • 6,208

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Freedom2013
                  Marco Antonio Barrera
                  Manny Pacquiao
                  Wladimir Klitschko
                  Joe Calzaghe

                  Lennox Lewis

                  I'd rate those five ahead of James "Belly's Out" Toney, who was twice caught cheating with steroids. And how many times has Roid Jones been KOed?

                  Comment

                  • shutupmeg
                    Contender
                    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                    • Jan 2013
                    • 102
                    • 4
                    • 0
                    • 6,204

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Freedom2013
                    So you're a racist.

                    Are you a black supremacist from the Nation of Islam? A follower of Farrakhan?
                    You are insane for a having a guy like Calzaghe on the list over Mayweather. What has Calzaghe done that trumps what Mayweather have done? Do you seriously Think Zags resume is better than Floyds?

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP