Floyd Mayweather ATG or ATD (all time duck)?

[I Love Jesus!]

the truth is, floyd undefeated record would not be the focus of his legacy. if you decipher the history of all atg’s in the sport of boxing, historian and boxing fans rely more on the quality of opponents and fighting style.

floyd will be more remembered as a fighter with skills (boring style) but lacks the balls to fight worthy opponents.

floyd will come way short to even be included in the top 50 atg's.

floyd quacks a lot, so he is a duck.

yeah if he loses it will be even worse. It will expose his cherry picking hard

[I Love Jesus!]

If he goes 49 or 50-0 and continues with all the named guys for his last few bouts he will get his just due. Just look at Broner. Haters and fans alike get defensive when you compare the two. Broner is so..........not at Floyd's level it actually makes you appreciate Floyd more lol.

Na ur a jock sniffer so everything just makes u appreciate Floyd more even something that has nothing to do with him.

[torosboxing75]

yeah if he loses it will be even worse. It will expose his cherry picking hard

I always wondered what will happen to Floyd selling power if he loses.

[straightleft]

Floyd has an atg skills to compensate his good but not atg worthy resume. Come on just take a deep look at his resume.

Baldomir, Gatti, Ortiz and Guerrero were good wins but nothing special.

His worthy atg status wins came from beating past prime fighters like Oscar, Mosley, Cotto and bloated Hatton and Marquez. Except Marquez, we know pretty well the rest Pac sent them to hell and retirements.

[torosboxing75]

Floyd has an atg skills to compensate his good but not atg worthy resume. Come on just take a deep look at his resume.

Baldomir, Gatti, Ortiz and Guerrero were good wins but nothing special.

His worthy atg status wins came from beating past prime fighters like Oscar, Mosley, Cotto and bloated Hatton and Marquez. Except Marquez, we know pretty well the rest Pac sent them to hell and retirements.

Can't argue with this, it's what will always haunt his legacy.

[Mboxingclinic]

Floyd Mayweather will never be considered an ATG at least not in the level of the Alie's, Patterson's or even Haglers. He will always be known as the guy that knew how to avoid dangerous fighters in their prime and avoid others altogether!!! Once he takes a loss Floyd will be worth nothing.

[Marvellous1]

I think he thinks just because he is undefeated that makes him the greatest ever. Losses are so overrated. IIRC SRR lost 19 times. La Motta lost about 19 times. Basilio lost like 12 times.

Really good but not an ATG.

I agree that Mayweather thinks because he's done all he's done without losing, he's the greatest of all time. To me, that's all in his head. He's an all time great but not with other fighters in the upper echelons of the sport's history.

[Mboxingclinic]

I agree that Mayweather thinks because he's done all he's done without losing, he's the greatest of all time. To me, that's all in his head. He's an all time great but not with other fighters in the upper echelons of the sport's history.

It is all in his head and maybe a couple of Floyd Mayweather lovers that think just because he is undefeated that makes him ATG. Maybe top 50 but that's about it.

[The Hammer]

Mayweather demanding a catchweight for Alvarez, after bashing Pacquiao for fighting at catchweights, shows he's a hypocrite no ring warrior.

[Mboxingclinic]

Mayweather demanding a catchweight for Alvarez, after bashing Pacquiao for fighting at catchweights, shows he's a hypocrite no ring warrior.

He is constantly contradicting himself when he is scared of his opponent like when he said they asked Pac about fighting him and Pac responded they would have to talk to his promoter and Floyd was saying Pac was scared because of his response. And that is almost always the response that Floyd gives when he is asked the same question about a fighter he is scared of.