Let's Be Real: Pac is a top 5 GOAT

[Szef]

This whole 8 division thing is balls. I'm sure if there was as many weight divisions and titles previously as there is today then we'd of had many legitimate 8 division champions.

Terrific post. Green k sent

[piye]

Can't beleive I'm reading people saying he has wins over Mosley and Oscar like they hold any merit and then that Floyd ducked prime Mosley despite the fact he fought both Mosley and scar before PAC. He's top 50 very exciting if Floyd beats Camelot though he has a better win than anyone on PACs resume I know p4p guys like morales are better but head to head Camelot spanks them and us the harder fight for a 36 year old Floyd.

[BTTAG145]

Top 5 ahead of who?

Definitely not:
SRR
Armstrong
SRL
Willie Pep
Ali
Joe Louis
Duran
Jack Johnson
Jack Dempsey
Benny Lenoard
Greb
Joe Gans
Gene Tunney
Rocky Marciano
Chavez Sr
Hopkins

That is just 20 boxers and there are a lot more. So stop it.

[Silky_Smooth]

Great fighter. Top 100 maybe.

[EvilGenius]

Its about opinions...
For me he is definitely up there with one of the best of all time.

[Check_hooks]

I have him in the top 5 with Ali, SRR, BHop etc

[Doctor_Tenma]

De la hoya's resume better than manny's

Oscar fought guys that were- Chavez twice, Whitaker,Hopkins, Floyd, Manny, Shane twice, Tito, Ike, Vargas, Gatti, Ruelas, Molina, Leija, hernadez, Gonzalez, Yory boy, sturm, Paez, Oba


I thought Oscar had the best resume of the last 25 years
And im probably leaving off some guys

Unless winning didn't have any importance

[Jam Jars]

A couple of years ago most would have him top 2. When it's all said and done and the Manny mania is officially over he won't be mentioned near the top 15.

[StarPower]

Manny and Floyd are both top 50 somewhere. Which means they had an amazing careers.

[Phenom]

hype is over with now poeple are slowly coming down from full ****** mode they were on in 2009-2011

he would be ranked up there with DLH when its all said and done