Should Lucas Matthysse be in the top ten P4P?

[Jack Napier]

no, and screw p4p rankings anyway, only the top spot matters
Lucas is closing in on being the man in his division, that's what counts
he'll be the JWW world champ soon enough
he mighta been there already if not for 2 robberies

[IronDanHamza]

Mares has a better resume but I personally think Matthysse is a better fighter than Mares so I'd probably have Matthysse in my list instead of Mares.

[junior gong]

He shouldn't be in the top 10, ( however if I read the poll properly I'd have checked the tick box that'd place him in after a win against Garcia). For me fighters in the top 10 pound for pound should (at the least) be a dominant fighter in their division. As good as his reason string of victories are he lost to Zab Judah and Alexander, those fights aren't the robberies people make them out to be, as a result they shouldn't be overlooked.

Yes they were, and as for the Alexander fight goes, well you must have had shit in your eyes when watching that one.

[The Hammer]

Lucas will never be higher than my Prince.
Never

Okay, Leonard.

[Tom Cruise]

After Garcia definitely. If he then beats Khan (just to finish off the 140 tourney thingamy) and moves up and gets a decent couple wins 147 i reckon he moves into the 5.

All reliant on getting the fights made though, which isnt a formality if the past is anything to go by