Should Lucas Matthysse be in the top ten P4P?

[$Bullsfam$]

With wins over Judah, Devon, Soto, Peterson, he should be

Over Ward, Floyd, Marquez, Pac, Sergio, Froch, Rigo, Donaire, Mares, and even Wlad with his longevity at #1 even though it kills me to say it.

Like I said in my first post in this thread, people are getting way ahead of themselves, Let him be #1 in the division first.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Quote:

Originally Posted by .:: JSFD26 ::.

If he didn't have the 2 "losses" then yes

They weren't really losses, at least not the Alexander "loss".

Well, it is what it is. He would be on MY list but no one would put him there for obvious reasons.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[The Hammer]

Over Ward, Floyd, Marquez, Pac, Sergio, Froch, Rigo, Donaire, Mares, and even Wlad with his longevity at #1 even though it kills me to say it.

Why does it kill you to say it?

[_original_]

A case could be made, especially since the majority don't consider his two "losses" as legitimate. I think he's gonna bombard the list if he lights Danny Garcia up like most are predicting.

[$Bullsfam$]

Why does it kill you to say it?

Because the quality of opposition isn't there the heavyweight division is pathetic compared to any other era in the division. You have to respect his longevity at the top like Floyd Mayweather because it is boxing and its extremely hard to have such long winning streaks, but the quality of competition on his resume just isn't there.

O and he's boring as hell.

[gmc_rfc_06]

If have Broner on your list, then Matthysse should be on it.

To those who are realistic though, not until he beats Garcia. That would be actual wins over Garcia, Peterson, Judah, Devon Borexander...yeah, that would do it.

[Southpawology]

not yet but if he beats garcia oh hell yessss

[_original_]

If have Broner on your list, then Matthysse should be on it.

To those who are realistic though, not until he beats Garcia. That would be actual wins over Garcia, Peterson, Judah, Devon Borexander...yeah, that would do it.

Dont' forget Ajose and Soto.

[LeonardEllerbe]

No.

Top Ten P4P.

1- My Prince PrettyBoy Floyd Mayweather 44-0 # Money Team

2-Adrien Broner

3-Tim Bradley

4- Devon Alexander

5-Chad Dawson

6- Bernard Hopkins

7-Gulliermo Jones

8-Bernstane Stiverne

9-D Bomb Wilder

10- Bryant Jennings

[techliam]

No.

Top Ten P4P.

1- My Prince PrettyBoy Floyd Mayweather 44-0 # Money Team

2-Adrien Broner

3-Tim Bradley

4- Devon Alexander

5-Chad Dawson

6- Bernard Hopkins

7-Gulliermo Jones

8-Bernstane Stiverne

9-D Bomb Wilder

10- Bryant Jennings

This made my morning!