Who is NSB most overrated fighter?

[Barn]

Matthysse means business and when he smashes Peterson with a right hand at 1:37 into Round 3 you'll all understand.

[Money_May]

ooooh russel jr. good call forgot about that dude! def overrated!

I had hopes for him.

[IronDanHamza]

Probably Andre Dirrell, some people will put him up there with Ward, Froch etc but really, who has he beat?

I agree with this.

Dirrell is talented but I think even his talent is overrated.

[New England]

it was nonito donaire. now he's lost and it's proven why he's overrated. he was a one trick pony. when he's not landing huge punches he doesn't look like anything special. take his huge punches away and he's nothing special.

actually, scratch that. before rigoneaux had a great win, or looked great anywhere other than a few spots over the course of a 12 round fight, he was the most overrated. this was pre donaire, obviously, where he showed his value.

i've never seen a fighter get as much unwarranted praise as rigondeaux got after rico ramos. it was rico flipping ramos... he was a sh#t fighter who had done nothing, and has gone on to lose or look like garbage in every fight since.


the difference is that rigondeaux has now lived up to most of the hype. some people are saying he's a hall of famer, etc, and that's overrating him, but calling him one of the best p4p in the world right now is appropriate, IMO.

[$tate of Mind]

Alvarez
Matthysee

And this is from a fan of both.

Agreed, those are the first names I thought of.

[Jam Jars]

Carl froch , he's defantly top 5 at smw. But he lost against Kessler and ward should of lost to Dirrel and was losing on the cards to Taylor till he got lucky . Froch is good but people putting him at 8 or 9 pfp is just ******

Froch is the fighter everyone wishes every boxer was like, will fight anyone and gives 100% every time out.

[SpeedKillz]

I had hopes for him.

yea me too, at one point. not for long though...

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Weebler what did you score Direll-Froch?

Dirrell beat AA and Froch.

[$tate of Mind]

Matthysse means business and when he smashes Peterson with a right hand at 1:37 into Round 3 you'll all understand.

I will give him props IF he wins. I've seen posters say he could beat Mayweather, based on what? Beating Mike Dallas Jr. give me a break

[LeG00N]

Mayweather
Broner
Garcia
Cotto
Lara
Rigo
Ward