More impressive performance, Rigo over Donaire or Floyd over Guerrero ?

[Deevel916]

More meaningful win?

Rigo over Nonito Donaire, Guerrero isn't even a top fighter.

now more impressive I have to say Floyd's, even though the opponent shouldn't even be in the ring with his level of skill, Floyd actually threw combos and took chances, Rigo just threw like a handful of shots just keeping his arm out and foot out to make it uncomfortable for Nonito to come in. It was extremely boring and cautious, Floyd actually showed defense, and counter punching and threw way more power shots and punches than Rigo.

He did? I didnt see not one combo thrown by Floyd that night. I may have to rewatch it.

[joesaiditstrue]

Rigo / Donaire, Guerrero arguably won 3 rounds. Donaire won 1 round (and without the KD, he loses that round)

[joesaiditstrue]

Mayweather outlanded and had a higher connection %. He didn't run anywhere near as much as rigondeaux did either, so I'd give it to Floyd. P4P, Floyd ****s all over rigondeaux.

nah, Guerrero wasn't even a P4P fighter. Donaire was on most people's top 5. Rigo outclassed a top 5 P4P fighter in his 13th pro fight

let that sink in for a minute

[hectari]

He did? I didnt see not one combo thrown by Floyd that night. I may have to rewatch it.

Well I mean he threw more than one punch, I remember him throwing a few right hands back to back, would you consider that a combo?

But he threw way more shots than Rigo. Rigo was super duper cautious it was boring. I enjoyed Floyd Mayweathers skills at least he was throwing shots.

[ab4life]

Mayweather outlanded and had a higher connection %. He didn't run anywhere near as much as rigondeaux did either, so I'd give it to Floyd. P4P, Floyd ****s all over rigondeaux.

You don't think this has to do with Rigo fighting a p4p one punch knock out artist in Donaire as opposed to the less dangerous Guerrero?

[SlySlickSmooth]

Guerrero was a mismatch and the scores came out exactly as I thought. I scored it myself and only gave Guerrero 2 rounds(1st and 12th) you could of given him 2 as well I suppose.

[MR PUNCHOUT]

Personally I would say may/guerrero bc flyod landed 60% of his power punches! Ridgondeaux got caught slipping and got dropped so may/guerrero more impressive to me but both were excellent performances!

[HanzGruber]

nah, Guerrero wasn't even a P4P fighter. Donaire was on most people's top 5. Rigo outclassed a top 5 P4P fighter in his 13th pro fight

let that sink in for a minute

op asked performance. Obviously rigo has the better win since donaire was p4p, floyd lost maybe 1, and gave one away

[ИATAS]

Rigondeaux by far. Not only was Donaire much bigger, he was top 5 p4p and the lineal champion. The skill level between Donaire vs Guerrero is huge as well.

[TBear]

Rigondeaux!!!!