Does Canelo make your Top 10 P4P list?

[_Gatti_]

Not Yet...but his next fight depending on who, will put him in there!

[daggum]

i think we can all agree guerrero shouldn't be on any p4p list. why do people think he's good? cause he moved up a lot of weight divisions fighting fringe contenders? wow i'm sold.

[Chiboxing123]

1lil floyd
2ward
3jmm
4sergio
5wlad
6rigo
7manny
8mares
9nonito
10 Froch
11canelo

[Tha_Greatest]

Not Yet...but his next fight depending on who, will put him in there!

if canelo fights gay azz semi retired stiff cotto (u Know, the one that floyd and Trout fought), will canelo beating that trash azz version of cotto be enough to get him in your p4p list

[daggum]

according to the ring-A fighter’s accomplishments in the recent past can be a factor to determine his place in the ratings. so why is floyd still #1? beating guys like ortiz and cotto? canelo just beat the guy that beat cotto and the guy that beat ortiz. recent past=canelo p4p #1 proof! remove that fraud!

[Jack Napier]

My previous list:

1. Mayweather
2. Ward
3. Marquez
4. Martinez
5. Wlad
6. Rigondeaux
7. Bradley
8. Mares
9. Dawson
10. Hopkins

My new list:

1. Mayweather
2. Ward
3. Marquez
4. Martinez
5. Wlad
6. Rigondeaux
7. Canelo
8. Bradley
9. Mares
10. Dawson

I feel terrible for taking out Hopkins though.

Why did I put Canelo at #7? Because size vs size, Canelo is a monster and he is one the top 10 best fighters in boxing right now.

you seem to be joking with this thread
but seriously, how is Floyd ahead of Ward?
why is Bradley even on there?
why is Dawson on there?
and where is Froch? Kessler robbed him and a Ward loss isn't damaging

[4Corners]

you seem to be joking with this thread
but seriously, how is Floyd ahead of Ward?
why is Bradley even on there?
why is Dawson on there?
and where is Froch? Kessler robbed him and a Ward loss isn't damaging

Mayweather's last 3 fights were P4P #3 Mosley, #2 147 Ortiz, and #1 154 Cotto.

Ward's last 3 have been Abraham, Froch #2 168, and Dawson #10 P4P. Dawson was weight drained clearly though. Had Ward went up to 175, captured the lineal title there, I'd say Ward is 100% #1.

My list is this...

Mayweather
Ward
Marquez
Sergio
Rigondeaux
Wlad
Pacquiao
Donaire
Mares
Froch

[Jack Napier]

Mayweather's last 3 fights were P4P #3 Mosley, #2 147 Ortiz, and #1 154 Cotto.

Ward's last 3 have been Abraham, Froch #2 168, and Dawson #10 P4P. Dawson was weight drained clearly though. Had Ward went up to 175, captured the lineal title there, I'd say Ward is 100% #1.

My list is this...

Mayweather
Ward
Marquez
Sergio
Rigondeaux
Wlad
Pacquiao
Donaire
Mares
Froch

don't even care much for these listings as a whole
it's more the #1 spot that piques interest
there's 0 justification for Floyd being ahead of Ward
Mosley was shot, Ortiz is pedestrian, and Cotto was badly past it
Shane/Cotto are simply bigger names then Ward's opposition
but Ward's been mopping up ranked SMW guys in succession
he's unified and cleansed his division, claimed lineage in doing so
Floyd's last big win was Hatton in 07

[-DSG-]

Mayweather,ward,Marquez,Martinez,wlad,rigo,Bradley ,mares,froch,broner.

[Tha_Greatest]

you seem to be joking with this thread
but seriously, how is Floyd ahead of Ward?
why is Bradley even on there?
why is Dawson on there?
and where is Froch? Kessler robbed him and a Ward loss isn't damaging

that p4p list is seriously screwed, top to bottom and im not even trolling on this post, ward is #1, all the other questions you posted are really legit logical questions, at least broner aint up their though