Does Canelo make your Top 10 P4P list?

[piojo del norte]

Canelo was 172 and trout was 171 and Canelo still put it on him, what is your excuse now?

Same weight, trout had a longer reach and height. What now? Any more excuses from the canelo haters?

Size v. size??? The guy rehydrated 18 pounds (172 pounds) for his last fight. How would he do against a 168 pound GGG or a 165 -167 pound Martinez?

And no I do not have him in my top 10.

[Mister Wolf]

I like Canelo's wins over Trout, Lopez, and old Mosley rather than Bradley's win over Provodnikov, Draw with Pacquiao, and win over an old Casamayor.

You forgot Bradley's wins over Witter, Holt, Peterson, Alexander, and Abregu.

[-Kev-]

Canelo was 172 and trout was 171 and Canelo still put it on him, what is your excuse now?

Same weight, trout had a longer reach and height. What now? Any more excuses from the canelo haters?

Exactly. It's why I asked my rhetorical question on how much did Trout gained.

You forgot Bradley's wins over Witter, Holt, Peterson, Alexander, and Abregu.

Those wins go beyond a couple of years though.

If I go back as deep as Witter for Bradley in 2008, then i'd have to dig out Pacquiao from his graveyard, Donaire, and put Dawson even higher because dating back to 2008, he has Hopkins, Johnson twice, Tarver twice, Diaconu, plus he is the current 175 Ring champion with only 2 losses and one of them not even being at 175.

[SplitSecond]

I know you two are Pac/Donaire fans. Why don't you guys post your P4P list so we can all have a laugh at the real trolls

no need, rigondeaux can only ride on the donaire win, the fact you have him in your top 5 proves you know how big a big win and achievement beating donaire was

but you're such a little hater you'd put dawson who got his ass handed to him by pascal(****in average fellow here) and ward
then bradley who got his ass handed to him by pacquiao and basically was only awarded a victory vs provodnikov for surviving the fight

ahead of a guy who never came close to losing for over a decade and destroyed all the guys that were meant to challenge him bar one

stop trollin son

[-Kev-]

no need, rigondeaux can only ride on the donaire win, the fact you have him in your top 5 proves you know how big a big win and achievement beating donaire was

but you're such a little hater you'd put dawson who got his ass handed to him by pascal(****in average fellow here) and ward
then bradley who got his ass handed to him by pacquiao and basically was only awarded a victory vs provodnikov for surviving the fight

ahead of a guy who never came close to losing for over a decade and destroyed all the guys that were meant to challenge him bar one

stop trollin son

Post your P4P list. I wanna laugh.

[Tha_Greatest]

You forgot Bradley's wins over Witter, Holt, Peterson, Alexander, and Abregu.

bradleys last 2 fights were terrible for his stock, he did everything wrong except lose in a bad fight vs pac and then he couldnt box vs a brawler so that fight was made exciting but it still was a terrible fight(if you are a boxer) bradley has fought bad in his last 2

[BafanaBafana]

How many pounds did Trout rehydrated?

He was a pound or two lighter, but Trout is neither Martinez nor Golovkin (going back to my post), and neither is he Lara. He did however, have the style to complicate Canelo so I give Ginger props for his performance (even though I scored the fight for Trout as many others here did). Canelo proved to be better than I thought (he has improved considerably since his first few title fights), but his display Saturday wasn't P4P material and neither is his resume (at present).

[HanzGruber]

CAnelo isn't even above broner in p4p lol. Neither of them are top 10 but cAnelo up there is just dumb

[-Kev-]

He was a pound or two lighter, but Trout is neither Martinez nor Golovkin (going back to my post), and neither is he Lara. He did however, have the style to complicate Canelo so I give Ginger props for his performance (even though I scored the fight for Trout as many others here did). Canelo proved to be better than I thought (he has improved considerably since his first few title fights), but his display Saturday wasn't P4P material and neither is his resume (at present).

And then when Canelo beats Martinez, Lara, or Golovkin, you will say "Well, Lara, Golovkin, and Martinez are no Andre Ward, Carl Froch, or Bernard Hopkins...how about that cowardly red head go up and face them!"

Sorry that you had Trout winning. You can not win a fight with jabs alone. Trout took the whole "Jab is the most important punch in boxing" to a whole new level. And being Paustin Troutanaggi, his power punches would feel like jabs anyway, that is if he would have actually landed them. Which he didn't, he made Canelo look like Pernell Whitaker.

[Tha_Greatest]

CAnelo isn't even above broner in p4p lol. Neither of them are top 10 but cAnelo up there is just dumb

i dont actually care about canelo not making peoples list, lol, that said, canelos win over miguel el titere vazquez is now a seriously better win than anything broners ever accomplished, broner and bradley dont belong in the list, hopkins belongs more than broner by far