Nonito Donaire is P4P the #1 Fighter In Boxing

[puga]

He didnt fight the best. Arce and Naervez had no chance to defeat nonito given the style they fight and the size differential going into the fight. That doesn't mean Nonito doesn't deserve credit for winning all 4 fights and he earned FOTY.

he did fight the best.. he fought narvaez after he beat montiel who was the best at 118 and arce after nishioka who was also the best at 122...

[Angelo89]

Easy? Then how come there's only one Floyd Mayweather?

I'm not even a Mayweather fan, but I'm not about to pretend what the guy does is even remotely "easy."

It's easy to stay undefeated when you only fight 5 times in 6 years and not even fight the best. Mayweather lost to Castillo, it was a bigger robbery than Pacquiao-Bradley and that fight was a big robbery as well.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Quote:

Originally Posted by gmc_rfc_06

Ward has already easily beat Froch, Kessler and Dawson....that is 3 elite, pound-for-pound level fighters. It's not just a great resume, it's the skill-set, Ward can do everything and fight in any style.

Then Mayweather, he has even more skill and ability to adjust to any style than Ward.

Those two are the clear #1 and #2 in the eyes of 90%.

Pacquiao leftovers? Mayweather has fought Oscar (before Pac), Hatton (before Pac), Mosley (before Pac), Marquez (who iced Pac).....

when was kessler ever a p4p fighter?..answer is never..dawson would've been a great win had ward fought him at 175 but instaed dawson came down something he had not made in 6 years...and abraham is C level fighter

after that who else?..bika in which he struggled, green and that bum miranda.. lol

ward has a decent resume for someone new to the p4p rankings but aint no way , shape or form better than nonito's at all ...

Sad. Trying to discredit Ward's resume.

Let me guess, you believe Donaire would beat Mayweather and Ward too?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Narvaez came up in weight and he was the best?

Ahhh they're all out at full force today!


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[puga]

Sad. Trying to discredit Ward's resume.

Let me guess, you believe Donaire would beat Mayweather and Ward too?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

and not really ..i think ward esp is bad news for nonito p4p.. floyd beats him too but not easily...

and i did not lie about wards resume..it's really easy to find out who's got a better one...

[puga]

Narvaez came up in weight and he was the best?

Ahhh they're all out at full force today!


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

who said that?

[puga]

It's easy to stay undefeated when you only fight 5 times in 6 years and not even fight the best. Mayweather lost to Castillo, it was a bigger robbery than Pacquiao-Bradley and that fight was a big robbery as well.

you talking out of your @ss now ... i also had castillo beating floyd but it was close... bradley won 3 rounds max....

[shade darkar]

Ward and Mayweather remain easily the top 2, in whatever order you prefer. They are simply FAR more skilled, well rounded and capable of many more things. Donaire is good, but he's got work to do before even getting above Martinez and Marquez, let alone the two clear best P4P fighters.

i have to disagree with that to be honest. mayweather should be considered the p4p number 1, but i dont see how people rate ward over marquez. i personally consider marquez to be more skilled than ward.

i think ward is right up there aswell but i think he has been slightly over rated because he won the super 6. if you actually have a look at what fights he had in the super 6, they were not that super!

[CubanGuyNYC]

It's easy to stay undefeated when you only fight 5 times in 6 years and not even fight the best. Mayweather lost to Castillo, it was a bigger robbery than Pacquiao-Bradley and that fight was a big robbery as well.

Mayweather-Castillo was close, not a robbery, the same as the Pacquiao-Marquez fights (with the obvious exception of the final bout). Pacquiao-Bradley was a robbery.

It may be easier to stay undefeated at Floyd's pace, but it's far from "easy." Donaire is a very good fighter with some impressive recent accomplishments; there's no need to put Mayweather down in order to build Nonito up.

[Angelo89]

Mayweather-Castillo was close, not a robbery, the same as the Pacquiao-Marquez fights (with the obvious exception of the final bout). Pacquiao-Bradley was a robbery.

It may be easier to stay undefeated at Floyd's pace, but it's far from "easy." Donaire is a very good fighter with some impressive recent accomplishments; there's no need to put Mayweather down in order to build Nonito up.

I'm not putting Mayweather down, my Top 3 is Donaire, then Ward, then Mayweather. Having a fighter as your 3rd best fighter p4p is very respectful. I just feel Donaire has earned it by fighting 4 times last year and destroying them all.