Originally posted by The Gambler1981
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Whats is YOUR interpretation of Ring Generalship?
Collapse
-
-
Originally posted by Russian Crushin View PostYes pick whichever promoter gave you more money for their fighter to win
It isn't that hard to pick a winner if you use all the criteria available.
Comment
-
Originally posted by The Gambler1981 View PostA judge should almost never score a round even~ there is enough to pick from that a judge should be able to make the call.
If you score a ton of rounds even you aren't a judge~
i agree. a professional judge should never score a round even, unless there is a point deduction
i don't mind somebody like you or I scoring a live fight even, though. sometimes there's just not enough to make an educated distinction. you end up just picking with your gut. in those cases you can score a round even.
if i drop by the RBR and i score a round even, i want you beefing with me over it
Comment
-
Originally posted by Russian Crushin View PostYea cuz you judge rounds on who landed the best and most effective punches
Comment
-
Originally posted by boxfan1983 View PostI can see how people say whoever contols the pace of the fight BUT what about high volume pressure fighters? For instance guys like Paul Williams and Antonio Margarito would throw well over 100 punches every round but could easily lose a decision to a pot shotter. IMO if a guy is getting off over 100 punches (¬ hitting air) that could be considered controling the pace, thats why the rules of judging are so outdated...
Comment
-
Originally posted by New England View Posti like "utilizing the ring."
it can be if you're landing the more meaningful punches on your bike, or putting the mustard on him before you run away, the way khan used to get away with before he hit the world class.
aggression is only as good as the landed punches it affords you.
Comment
-
Originally posted by New England View Posti agree. a professional judge should never score a round even, unless there is a point deduction
i don't mind somebody like you or I scoring a live fight even, though. sometimes there's just not enough to make an educated distinction. you end up just picking with your gut. in those cases you can score a round even.
if i drop by the RBR and i score a round even, i want you beefing with me over it
If someone scores more than 1 round even I have got on people for that, because if you are judging you need to be picking a winner and not being wishy-washy.
Comment
-
Originally posted by bojangles1987 View PostThat's why ring generalship doesn't matter nearly as much as who is landing the best punches. Criteria like ring generalship is vastly overvalued by some posters.
Comment
Comment