Who is higher on the ATG list: Floyd Mayweather (so far) or Roberto Duran?

[Nay_Sayer]

Duran has the W over a PRIME SRL. Hard to top that...

[Nay_Sayer]

Fight GGG at 160 and then might be able to re revise Floyds career.

I'm sorry but NO. Beating Bumlovkin does not elevate Mayweather's status and it certainly does NOT put Mayweather over Duran. Roberto's dismantling of Iran Barkley is a much better win than Mayweather beating the Triple Duck @ 160. Exactly WHO has Bumlovkin beaten?

[therealpugilist]

Duran has the W over a PRIME SRL. Hard to top that...

True but may weather also beat more champs,hall of famers, def his titles more, more lineal titles in 60 less fights


Depth of resume means more than one big win....JCC never beat an Alexis arguello like Pryor but he definitely beat better comp overall @ 140 so he should rank higher

[fanofslug]

Emotions aside, Mayweather is and should be ranked number 1 on the ATG list. Yeah, Duran was good, but this isn't even debatable. Anyone who voted otherwise, sucks **** by choice.

[The Hammer]

This joker really thought that it was going to get changed to an NC

It there was any justice, it would be.

Floyd shouldn't be allowed to cheat.

[b00g13man]

This joker really thought that it was going to get changed to an NC

[daggum]

It there was any justice, it would be.

Floyd shouldn't be allowed to cheat.

floyd cleaning up the sport! you get an exemption and you get an exemption and you get an exemption!

[ADP02]

True but may weather also beat more champs,hall of famers, def his titles more, more lineal titles in 60 less fights


Depth of resume means more than one big win....JCC never beat an Alexis arguello like Pryor but he definitely beat better comp overall @ 140 so he should rank higher

Sorry but most of those fights of Floyd's can be criticized. Just use your logic that you used in the past when you criticized or put a fighter a few notches lower for fighting fighters when they were less than prime or for other reasons.


and I laughed when you tried to twist it like as if it was better to have fought 49 times (for Floyd) than Duran fighting ~120 fights!

Floyd got a lineal title by beating ....... no name Baldomir! Sounds pathetic if you put that name next to that!

Nice try but you fail.

[Chrismart]

Sorry but most of those fights of Floyd's can be criticized. Just use your logic that you used in the past when you criticized or put a fighter a few notches lower for fighting fighters when they were less than prime or for other reasons.


and I laughed when you tried to twist it like as if it was better to have fought 49 times (for Floyd) than Duran fighting ~120 fights!

Floyd got a lineal title by beating ....... no name Baldomir! Sounds pathetic if you put that name next to that!

Nice try but you fail.

Carlos 'The Lineal' Baldomir always gets his daily mention.

[ADP02]

Carlos 'The Lineal' Baldomir always gets his daily mention.

This is the only time he ever gets mentioned. Imagine, they do it to try to prop up Floyd's resume but often do not even mention Baldomir's name because when people are reminded, they snicker, laugh, giggle, ......