Who is higher on the ATG list: Floyd Mayweather (so far) or Roberto Duran?

[SplitSecond]

I was gonna come in here to say "unquestionably Duran", but the poll speaks for itself.

[creekrat77]

I'm not saying he wasn't skilled. I just say that Floyd has better skills, which I believe he does. However the level of competition is not comparable because Duran beat way better guys. Ray Leonard is better than anyone Floyd beat.

Completley different perspectives both guys had for boxing. Floyds style revolves around not getting hit. Durans is laying out an @ss whooping whilst efficiently working around his opponents offense. If you ask me, taking a few shots while slipping most inside the pocket at a high speed feverish rate is more impressive then Floyd jabbing to the midsection, shoulder rolling a quick combo on the ropes and running out of his opponents range

[Killer_of_Sheep]

Duran and its not even debatable.

Duran KO of Ernesto Marcel is as better win than 1/10 of Mayweather's top victories (i think only Pacquiao is a better victory, really).

Prime Ken Buchanan and Esteban de Jesus are better than the whole Floyd run through super-feather to light-welter.

Hell, even Guts Ishimatsu is better than most Floyd's top victories.

[The Hammer]

if you have duran and Manny on the same level then you have to have Floyd ahead of duran

Floyd fought a faded version of Pacquiao, and because of Floyd's ILLEGAL injection it should be changed to a "no contest" anyway.

[Left Hook Tua]

duran.

beating ray > barely outpointing pac

duran was ped free too.

[Weltschmerz]

Oh my... please don't even put that little faqqot in same sentence as the great Duran.

[The Big Dunn]

Floyd fought a faded version of Pacquiao, and because of Floyd's ILLEGAL injection it should be changed to a "no contest" anyway.

Freedom, please find another excuse. Manny lost. You picked him to win. Get over it, move on.

As for this thread, I wish Floyd had fought 60 guys you didn't know. I imagine you'd be far more critical of these wins if they were on his resume instead of Duran's.

Floyd is retired so how about you retire from bigoted and bias posting. Oh yeah, Ward is still better than GGG so I guess you aren't going anywhere.

[The Big Dunn]

duran.

beating ray > barely outpointing pac

duran was ped free too.

I have Duran as well but a question for you Tua.

what about losing to Kirkland Laing and quitting? How do we factor these into his resume?

[GTTofAK]

This is going to end up like who ranks higher Babe Ruth or Barry Bonds.

[Left Hook Tua]

Oh my... please don't even put that little faqqot in same sentence as the great Duran.

esteban de jesus - jose luis castillo
ray leonard - carlos baldomir
iran barkley - victor ortiz

like mirror images.