floyd's success above 135 is mostly based on other..

[GoldenAssassin]

Zab Judah and Carlos Baldomir or Miguel Cotto and Antonio Margarito. Which names look better on your resume?

Cotto was getting knocked around by Torres when Judah and Floyd fought.

[puga]

Do you not have a reason?

yes i do ..younger shane >>>anything that floyd has done at ww..ofcourse floyd's got the quantity obviously...

[GoldenAssassin]

Are you serious, man? IDK how many spots exactly but he'd be a lock as an ATG.

He's already a lock for top 50 ATG.

[IMDAZED]

yes i do ..younger shane >>>anything that floyd has done at ww..ofcourse floyd's got the quantity obviously...

Because of one win? Is Vernon Forrest a greater welter than all of them? He beat a younger Mosley.

[AztecWanker]

Cotto was getting knocked around by Torres when Judah and Floyd fought.

So what? He won that fight by TKO. He then moved up, slapped Quintana, Zab, and Mosley (fresher Mosley than the version Floyd fought) around. He was a top dogg at 147. Floyd vs. Cotto was THE fight to be made in '08. Guess what happened? Floyd retired.

He's already a lock for top 50 ATG.

That's cool. Where would you have him if he fought prime, undefeated Cotto and Margarito after beating prime, undefeated Cotto?

[puga]

Because of one win? Is Vernon Forrest a greater welter than all of them? He beat a younger Mosley.

like i said , floyd got it by quantity , not quality ..dont know why you keep pushin...

[IMDAZED]

like i said , floyd got it by quantity , not quality ..dont know why you keep pushin...

You said Cotto has a better resume. Now Floyd does.

[GoldenAssassin]

So what? He won that fight by TKO. He then moved up, slapped Quintana, Zab, and Mosley (fresher Mosley than the version Floyd fought) around. He was a top dogg at 147. Floyd vs. Cotto was THE fight to be made in '08. Guess what happened? Floyd retired.


That's cool. Where would you have him if he fought prime, undefeated Cotto and Margarito after beating prime, undefeated Cotto?

Did you not read my original post? How am I justifying Floyd's retirement? Read the post next time.

I said he missed Cotto in 08. The first line of my first post. But somehow I'm justifying his retirement LOL

[AztecWanker]

Did you not read my original post? How am I justifying Floyd's retirement? Read the post next time.

I said he missed Cotto in 08. The first line of my first post. But somehow I'm justifying his retirement LOL

Ok, cool. Floyd will forever have Zab and Baldo instead of Cotto and Tony. I will LAFF at that for the rest of my life. Good night, amigo.

[GoldenAssassin]

Ok, cool. Floyd will forever have Zab and Baldo instead of Cotto and Tony. I will LAFF at that for the rest of my life. Good night, amigo.

Like people will ever remember Margarito lmao. Now THAT is laughable.

Floyd>Mosley>Margarito