Who ranks higher on your ATG List. Evander Holyfield or Floyd Mayweather Jr

[UnicornGirl]

Holyfield or Floyd.

[DeadLikeMe]

This is hard for me because these are probably my two favorite fighters of my lifetime (I'm 29). Gotta give the nod to the warrior.

[Russian Crushin]

Cmon.......

[IronDanHamza]

Holyfield and it's not arguable.

I'm not even an overly big fan of him either.

[dan_cov]

The real deal.

[A-Wolf]

Evander Holyfield

[GoldSugar]

Both are top 50 ATGs. Splitting hairs in this one and it's tough.

[NEELZ]

This is absolutely a no-brainer. The Real Deal Holyfield is far superior IMO. A real warrior, not too much a Pretty Boy. He beat Tyson at his best. Fought Bowe at his best. Epic battles. Took the kind of fights that Mayweather is avoiding at all costs.

[kiDynamite92]

Resume wise it don't get much better than Holyfield, who was the greater fighter at their weight class? I'd be confident enough to say that Holyfield was a greater fighter in both cruiser and heavyweight than Floyd and all his weight classes.

[4Corners]

Holyfield slightly in my opinion. I have him around the Top 20 All-Time. He beat a prime Bowe and a past prime-still good Tyson. 2 very good wins.