Does Mayweather Jr deserve the p4p #1 spot?

[Troav]

I don't think he deserves it anymore, he's not active enough.

[Bushidō]

No.

Andre Ward is absolutely number 1 p4p

[Soda_Popinski]

Yes, he deserves to be #1...there was nothing to debate before last night, and there isn't after last night...

Ward is, and should be the solid #2 and heir apparent to the P4P throne

[!! Shawn]

Bradley doesn't belong on that list Marquez should be ahead of Ward

I disagree, Bradley catches a lot of flack on here, but I had him beating Pacquiao. He is a fighter that is much better than he is given credit for.

He has true craft, intelligence, and slickness, and speed.

Marquez doesn't belong on the list because of the diminished skills he showed in the Pacquiao fight.

Don't get my wrong, Marquez is one of my favorite fighters of all time, but he was having real problems pulling the trigger last night, and against a fighter in their prime he would have been in serious trouble.

He wouldn't have beaten Bradley, Alexander, or Matthyse last night.

Unfortunately, I feel father time has finally caught up with him, much like it has with Pacquiao.

The man has boxed 462 rounds in his career. 30 more than Roy Jones, 4 more than Bernard Hopkins, 40 more than Erik Morales...

[revs1227]

no he is an entertainer not a fighte r

ward
martinez
jmm
donair
pac
bradley

[IronDanHamza]

I'm guessing considering he was joint #2 that he'll go to #1 by default.

Unless Marquez moves to #1.

I'd be fine with both.

[Phenom]

Ward can;t be P4P for the simple reason he refused to fight for the lineal Ring and WBC and asked for Dawson to come down in weight instead

[Earl-Hickey]

No, it's time wladamir klitschko get his dues

[NEETzsche]

if you're going to hold inactivity against him, you should remove him from the list altogether rather than relegating him to a lower position as "punishment".

[Ring Leader]

thing is Marquez's win over Pacquiao is 10x better than Mayweathers best win.