Does Mayweather Jr deserve the p4p #1 spot?

[SirTomJones]

So far 44% think he is.

Care to defend yourselves?

[illmaticfighter]

Ward is number 1 close behind is floyd and serg whoever looks better in there next fight should take the crown.

[SirTomJones]

Ward is number 1 close behind is floyd and serg whoever looks better in there next fight should take the crown.

Why is Floyd close behind?

[Glamour Puss]

No, his resume is a joke. He's an expert at cherry picking "names" to make himself look unbeatable. These guys are always either too old, too small, or overrated like Hatton.

Ortiz was the only mildly serious fight he took since Castillo in 2003.

[!! Shawn]

I would put

ward #1
sergio #2
donaire #3 (despite his recent lackluster opposition you can't deny his talent)
Floyd #4
Bradley #5
Rigondeaux #6 (will be #1 when he knocks out donaire)

[Luilun]

In the past 9 years this is who Floyd has fought.

2003 (2 fights)
Victoriano Sosa
Phillip Ndou

2004 (1 fight)
DeMarcus Corley

2005 (3 fights)
Henry Bruseles
Arturo Gatti
Sharmba Mitchell

2006 (2 fights)
Zab Judah
Carlos Manuel Baldomir

2007 (2 fights and arguably his best year)
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton

2008 (no fights)

2009 (1 fight)
Juan Manuel Marquez

2010 (1fight)
Shane Mosley

2011 (1fight)
Victor Ortiz

2012 (1fight)
Miguel Cotto



only 4 fights since Hatton in 2007.

No fighting old has beens should put at the bottom of the list

[KnockUTheFukOut]

Did Mayweather fight Last Night? What is with the sudden talk about Mayweather

[Luilun]

I would put

ward #1
sergio #2
donaire #3 (despite his recent lackluster opposition you can't deny his talent)
Floyd #4
Bradley #5
Rigondeaux #6 (will be #1 when he knocks out donaire)

Bradley doesn't belong on that list Marquez should be ahead of Ward

[teddycanyon]

Mayweather has the established body of work to stay at #1 for the time being, but Ward is nipping at his heels. Problem for Ward is, there's nobody for the poor guy to fight he hasn't already beat! Maybe George Groves will prove to be decent, or Golovkin will come up in weight and he'll get some real competition. Or if he goes the Bernard Hopkins route and just fights any top contenders at SMW who come along regardless of what each individual fight means for a legacy, then he'll probably overtake Mayweather soon.
Donaire is probably sitting at #3 right now and if he moves up to featherweight and beats someone like Salido or Gamboa, I think you have to put him at #1. Closely following Donaire is Marquez right now and Pacman has slipped from #2 to #5. I put Sergio at #6 cause he was a little disappointing in the Chavez Jr. fight. Wlad takes #7, Bradley takes #8, Vitali and Abner Mares take #s 9 + 10.

[SirTomJones]

Did Mayweather fight Last Night? What is with the sudden talk about Mayweather

Well I assumed he just knocked Manny out?