Jose Luis Castillo VS Floyd Mayweather I, Who really won??

[IronDanHamza]

pac cleary won rounds 1,3,4,11, and 12. did marquez clearly win the other 7? no. therefore it can't be a robbery.

That's what I said.

[Spoon23]

Well I'll be damn.

This poll shows Floyd is not undefeated hahaha

[daggum]

In the 3rd fight?

I gave Pac 3 rounds in that fight, to me it wasn't even close.

The first two were toss-up decisions and Pac was winning the 4th was before the KO, but Marquez clearly win the 3rd fight.

well i'm not sure if you went into the fight with predetermined expectations but it was close. those 5 rounds i really don't see any case that marquez won any of them. marquez only clearly won 3 rounds himself. 5, 7, and 8. i really don't see any way pac won those. the other 4 rounds 2,6,9, and 10 were all very close. i think marquez prob slightly won 2 and 10 and pac slightly won 9. round 6 was so so close that you can argue either way or even 10-10. if you give all the very close rounds to marquez he wins. if you give pac even one of the close rounds its a draw. 2 and its a win for him. not sure why people scream robbery. i'm guessing its the expectations that pac was going to ko marquez easy so they gave marquez more credit simply for not being destroyed. also some people seem to think because the fight was fought at a slow pace that inherently favored marquez but you don't judge a fight the way you think its going to play out, you judge a fight based on what is happening and what happened was a very close fight with pac often getting the better of a slow paced fight, but yet people still gave marquez credit just because of the feel and pace of the fight and not necessarily the punches.

[junior gong]

The poll tells the story of this fight. Its a joke that floyd calls himself undefeated and acts in such a cowardly way to protect his non existent '0'.

[mann187]

Iv watched it twice and had it for castillo 7-5. No shame in him losing to him, he had a torn rotator cuff so the fact he made it close is impressive.

He atleast rematched him and got the win after, but castillo won the first by a round.

[fighter1234]

Max Kellerman's take on the fight:

http://a.espncdn.com/boxing/columns/kellerman_max/1373403.html

[betmen]

Floyd win, Floyd grab more rounds. Castillo land more power punches in last half of the fight but Floyd already secure 4-5 rounds in the first half of the fight then he close it magnificently in the championship round.

Floyd still undefeated

[Suckmedry]

Its really the definition of a toss up fight. From memory i think i scored it a draw.

[Monaco Slim]

Castillo clearly won. Floyd owes everything that he has to Bob Arum.

[K-DOGG]

From what I saw, Mayweather lost....but, it all depends on the judges and what they are looking for, as always.

Floyd got lucky that night.