Is Robert Guerrero a LEGIT Champioin??

[The Gambler1981]

Berto would have been his first defense, Aydin made him interim champion then he should have got elevated if the WBC went according to their rules any number of the several they have used to strip guys in the past.

[-PBP-]

Ah, man. Completely disregarding his "win"

Apparently the fans feel the same way. Even Tyson Fury got more votes than Bradley. lol:

Which of these rising stars will make the biggest impact in 2013?

Nonito Donaire 29.4%
Adrien Broner 22.5%
Saul Alvarez 17.8%
Gennady Golovkin 9.1%
Andre Ward 8%
Robert Guerrero 3.8%
Brandon Rios 3.1%
David Price 2.1%
Abner Mares 1.4%
Ricky Burns 1.3%
Tyson Fury 1%
Timothy Bradley 0.7%

Ring Magazine poll.

[MVOLT]

Least credible champion? Definitely Bradley...... he's worse than a paper champion he's an imposter, he shouldn't even be ranked at WW.

i have to agree with this

i have devon alexander higher then him on the WW rankings and Guerrero above both of them

[IronDanHamza]

Apparently the fans feel the same way. Even Tyson Fury got more votes than Bradley. lol:

Which of these rising stars will make the biggest impact in 2013?

Nonito Donaire 29.4%
Adrien Broner 22.5%
Saul Alvarez 17.8%
Gennady Golovkin 9.1%
Andre Ward 8%
Robert Guerrero 3.8%
Brandon Rios 3.1%
David Price 2.1%
Abner Mares 1.4%
Ricky Burns 1.3%
Tyson Fury 1%
Timothy Bradley 0.7%

Ouch.

You'd think coming over a win over Pacquaio you'd get more than 0.7% of the vote

[Rome-By-Ko]

Well you're saying no matter how you spin it, he wasn't ranked and didn't have a belt.

Well the same applies for Mayweather when he fought Ortiz so by the same logic, "no matter how you spin it" surely he wasn't a top fighter either.

He broke the rules but still, he was a top WW at the time.

I don't have to spin anything..Mayweather num 1 P4P(or two however ya like)and cash cow...Ortiz was kicking down May's door...Then there's Berto..A drug cheat..No spin just facts...

[IronDanHamza]

I don't have to spin anything..Mayweather num 1 P4P(or two however ya like)and cash cow...Ortiz was kicking down May's door...Then there's Berto..A drug cheat..No spin just facts...

Mayweather was unranked in the P4P list and at WW at the time.

He wasn't ranked anywhere.

Was he a top fighter?

[The Gambler1981]

Current WBC 147 rankings (although I don't know if it includes Guerrero-Berto, also may I add what a sorry ass list)

Floyd Mayweather
Robert Guerrero
1. Selcuk Aydin
2. Luis Carlos Abregu
3. Anton Novikov
4. Ed Paredes
5. Dennis Laurente
6. Leonard Bundu
7. Antonin Decaire
8. Andre Berto
9. Jesse Vargas
10. Victor Ortiz
11. Thomas Dulorme
12. Jorge Paez Jr.
13. Phil Lo Greco
14. Patrick Allotey
15. Josesito Lopez

[Rome-By-Ko]

Mayweather was unranked in the P4P list and at WW at the time.

He wasn't ranked anywhere.

Was he a top fighter?

Is this a trick question??

[Rome-By-Ko]

Mayweather was unranked in the P4P list and at WW at the time.

He wasn't ranked anywhere.

Was he a top fighter?

BTW Are you trying to compare Mayweather taking time off to Berto being suspended for using PEDS??Just curious...

[IronDanHamza]

Is this a trick question??

No, just a question.

You're saying Berto wasn't ranked and didn't have a belt at 147 thus wasn't a top fighter at 147. But the fact is, he was considered to be one of the Top fighters at 147 at the time of the Guererro fight hence why he was the favorite.

The same applies for Mayweather when he fought Ortiz. Wasn't ranked, didn't have a belt. But, he was still considered to be a Top fighter at WW at the time and in the world in general.