Is Joe Calzaghe an ATG?

[IMDAZED]

So what do yo people want?

SERIOUSLY?

You guys want Joe to apologize to Roy for clowning him?
Is that it?

It was all fun and games..
Roy did the same thing to the bums he fought brahs..

Doesn't make Calzaghe an ATG.

[orriray59]

Very true. I don't understand how people ignore how good Hopkins was at the time. And, while Joe was younger, he was still quite old in boxing terms.

Yup. The Pavlik fight is one of Hopkins' top 3 performances IMO, and it happened after Calzaghe beat him.

[UTEP]

"Is Joe Calzaghe an ATG"




yes

[Skittlez]

Andre Ward's best win was someone already beaten up by Calzaghe.

Calzaghe beat the very best and prime version of Kessler.

Ward did not.

[Skittlez]

Carl Froch has already done more than Joe to this point

has he?

has he really?

[Earl-Hickey]

you can smell the bias on this forum when you commonly hear people saying "ward is already atg" but yet calzaghe who had a fair bit better resume than ward has yet is not classed as one.

[techliam]

Yep, and they were in their prime too.

Jones.... in his prime? Are you serious?

Apologies if that was sarcasm. Just seems too ****** to be true

[thuggery]

Hardly a surprise that all of the Hopkins/Ward fans voted no. Jealousy?

[LeG00N]

I voted Yes...........

[IMDAZED]

you can smell the bias on this forum when you commonly hear people saying "ward is already atg" but yet calzaghe who had a fair bit better resume than ward has yet is not classed as one.

I'm not sure you've heard anyone say that.