Matthysse vs Alexander & Judah RBR!

[Juanma9]

Upon first (and only) viewing I thought Matthysse won both fights. I remember thinking at the time that the only possible way Alexander/Judah could be ahead on the scorecards is if the judges consistently gave all the close rounds to the hometown fighter.

[Weebler I]

Rounds I disagree with your scoring: 2,6,7,9

I gave R.2, R.6 and R.9 to Matthysse. Round 7 to Judah.

R.1 - Judah
R.2 - Matthysse
R.3 - Matthysse
R.4 - Matthysse
R.5 - Judah
R.6 - Matthysse
R.7 - Judah
R.8 - Judah
R.9 - Matthysse
R.10 - Matthysse (10-8)
R.11 - Matthysse
R.12 - Matthysse

I think this would be a more entertaining fight if they rematched, Judah sat in the pocket defensively for long periods just trying to make Matthysse miss.

[El Angel]

Alexander won, he took the W and that's that.

most ppl agree

Most do not agree. That's been widely panned as robbery. The KD is even more fuel to the fire. He only won 4 rounds and with a KD, there is no way Devon won.

[9 TREY GKB]

Most do not agree. That's been widely panned as robbery. The KD is even more fuel to the fire. He only won 4 rounds and with a KD, there is no way Devon won.

devon got the nod and that's what matters.

[Russian Crushin]

Round 9? Nobody got the "stuffing beat out of them" in round 9. Lucas threw more punches but was missing wildly and occasionally slapping. In other cases Judah was circling away or catching the punches with his glove. It was an ugly round altogether. Unless your scoring it based on "being more active" or giving the benefit of the doubt to the guy coming forward.

You wrote a whole paragraph question how lucas didnt win that round yet said NOTHING about what judah actually did to win it

[El Angel]

devon got the nod and that's what matters.

True, the only result that counts. But it didn't enhance Devon's rep and it seemed to bring more hate on him, even though it's not his job to score the fights.

[9 TREY GKB]

True, the only result that counts. But it didn't enhance Devon's rep and it seemed to bring more hate on him, even though it's not his job to score the fights.

hate=success

[El Angel]

hate=success

I guess we have different opinions on success. Floyd is hated on because he's that damn good. Devon is hated on because he has gotten suspect decisions in his hometown and laid an egg in the biggest fight of his career.

[-DSG-]

they really aren't hard to score. who's landing the punches? lucas. ok he gets the round. sounds easy. are people psyching themselves out by talking about jabs that hit air and footwork? who's landing the punches! wow judah got beat to hell in that round but i really liked his footwork!

yeah the alexander fight was bad matthyse cleary won that fight. i think the judah fight was closer but matthyse deserved the nod at worst he won 3 out of the first six rounds and he definetly swept the last 3 plus the knockdown equals 6-6 in rounds with the knock down being the difference

[daggum]

You wrote a whole paragraph question how lucas didnt win that round yet said NOTHING about what judah actually did to win it

judah didn't get ko'd. that's not enough to win the round. i mean he's still standing he must be winning. also look at that footwork!