What should the P4P Rankings look like

[Fists_of_Fury]

I should've voted other... these 2 guys are tied for P4P #1

[DARKSEID]

Currently mine is

1. Ward
2. Mayweather
3. Pacquiao
4. Marquez
5. Donaire

[NEETzsche]

people placing ward above mayweather are the boxing equivalent of hipsters.

[DARKSEID]

people placing ward above mayweather are the boxing equivalent of hipsters.

what are people who judge other people opinions like theirs is better without knowing why the boxing equivalent of?

[hugh grant]

Pacs no1. Id like to see Floyd vs Bradley just to see if Floyd can beat Bradley as good as Pac did.

And dont worry Floyd, we wont accuse you of fighting Pacs used goods and leftovers again like you did against Cotto. Of course Bradley is used goods, but he will have learnt from his defeat to Pac.

[WESS]

My top 5 cept I have Ward as #1.

Fair enough. The top 3 could easily be moved around. However Pac doesn't deserve for second to be top 5 compared to the names I (we) listed.

[Bushbaby]

Fair enough. The top 3 could easily be moved around. However Pac doesn't deserve for second to be top 5 compared to the names I (we) listed.

I mean if pfp was by definition a popularity contest, then of course he'd be top 5. But if we're honest with ourselves & respect the sport, then we should be able to name 5 better fighters by the definition of pfp alone.

[ИATAS]

1. Mayweather
2. Pacquiao
3. JMM
4. Ward
5. Martinez
6. Donaire
7. Wlad
8. Dawson
9. Cotto
10. Froch

[Biolink]

people placing ward above mayweather are the boxing equivalent of hipsters.

Meh. Agree, but disagree. To be honest he's probably the only one with a case over Money. He's fighting fairly often and shutting out high quality opposition and skill and technique wise one of very few who can look Money in the eyes. With disregard to ranking based on popularity and going off of opposition and what I actually see in the ring in terms of skills, he definitely has a case.

[Portman]

Mayweather is my number one, I don't see anyone beating him at the time being.

Andre Ward has a good set of skills and know how to dismantle boxers and tear apart their game plans, but I need to see how he fares against Dawson, before I will give him the 2nd spot.

Manny hasn't performed the way a P4P king should perform against his previous opponents and therefore I cannot place him number 1.. The whole thought of May-Pac fight has lost some of the appeal, judging on the way Pac looked in the recent fights. I think Mayweather would beat him considering how Pac looked versus Bradley & JMM. It could have been the best fight of this boxing generation, I just don't see it reaching that point now.

Sergio and JMM are up there too