who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker

[Larry the boss]

See this is why your thread turned to sh**. You're honestly looking at the names on both sides and not seeing that Whitaker beat better fighters?

no i am not seeing it at all

[Roman Moreno]

its one thing to say floyd's resume is better than pernell. thats cool, say it and back it up. its when u start backing it up with stupidity that ppl wil start making fun of u.

This all the way.

But, I want to throw this little "fact" out there. And, this is not for you. When Pac beat Morales both times. Morales was in the top 10 P4P "fact". What does that really mean? Anyone.

On paper Pac beat more champs than Leonard did. On paper. On paper Pac has more accomplishments than Leonard has...On paper. What does all this really mean?

[Larry the boss]

And by the way on paper sweet pea drew with Chavez so he only beat 19 champs to Floyd's 20. It'll probably be 22-23 by the time he retires.

yep.......................

[-PBP-]

better comp based on what???cause we are listing the names and rankings at the time and im not seeing that at all

Ramirez - hall of fame
Haugen - hall of fame
Chavez - hall of fame
Nelson - hall of fame

All of these guys were at their best when Whitaker fought them.

Then you have:

McGirt - p4p ranked fighter by ring magazine
Vazquez- undefeated champion who went on to beay Winky Wright
Rivera x 2 - undefeated champion at the time

[Larry the boss]

Ramirez - hall of fame
Haugen - hall of fame
Chavez - hall of fame
Nelson - hall of fame

All of these guys were at their best when Whitaker fought them.

Then you have:

McGirt - p4p ranked fighter by ring magazine
Vazquez- undefeated champion who went on to beay Winky Wright
Rivera x 2 - undefeated champion at the time

thank you for actually backing stuff up with facts thats all i ask

[-PBP-]

And by the way on paper sweet pea drew with Chavez so he only beat 19 champs to Floyd's 20. It'll probably be 22-23 by the time he retires.

Nah fucc paper. That don't belong here.

On paper Floyd split decisioned de la hoya. You believe that? Hell no. Pure domination.

On paper Floyd was a bronze medalist. You believe that? Hell no. Pure robbery.

Was Roy Jonez really a bronze medalist in Korea?

Did Roy Jones really lose to Montell Griffin when he had cuz on his knees.

Watch the fights and be your own judge.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Ramirez - hall of fame
Haugen - hall of fame
Chavez - hall of fame
Nelson - hall of fame

All of these guys were at their best when Whitaker fought them.

Then you have:

McGirt - p4p ranked fighter by ring magazine
Vazquez- undefeated champion who went on to beay Winky Wright
Rivera x 2 - undefeated champion at the time

I don't know about Nelson being at his best, though he was still very good. Haugen in the fall of fame, I'd like to know how...

Whitaker's career is still greater than Floyd's though.

[Larry the boss]

I still have to go with Floyd man he has just accomplished so much more and his longevity and consistency

[-PBP-]

I don't know about Nelson being at his best, though he was still very good. Haugen in the fall of fame, I'd like to know how...

Whitaker's career is still greater than Floyd's though.

32-1... what was he 31 years old?

He was still a very strong opponent. He even went to Austrailia years later and knocked out an undefeatex hall of famer in his back yard.

I think that's definitely a very strong win for Pea.


And Haugen is a World boxing hof inductee.

But i like to look is what fighters go onto do after they suffer a defeat.

[Doctor_Tenma]

32-1... what was he 31 years old?

He was still a very strong opponent. He even went to Austrailia years later and knocked out an undefeatex hall of famer in his back yard.

I think that's definitely a very strong win for Pea.


And Haugen is a World boxing hof inductee.

But i like to look is what fighters go onto do after they suffer a defeat.

Yeah I seen the Fenech fights, don't know if I can say Nelson was at his best at LW, still a great win for Whitaker nonetheless. Yeah that I saw, only that I fail to see how he was inducted.