who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker

[Larry the boss]

In no way shape or form Mosley was p4p #3 when Floyd fought him or Corrales being inside the top 10 p4p.

Mosley was p4p#3 that is a fact.he was also the #1 ww after beating margo.And Corrales was undefeated and a top 10 p4p fighter.those are facts

[Larry the boss]

Ring Magazine #3 in 2009

Corrales ring magazine #5 in 2000

facts..........................

[Light_Speed]

The statement that Floyd beat more champions is incorrect. I even gave Floyd the benefit of the doubt and inclufrd NABF and NABO champions.

Champions defeated by Mayweather:

Hernandez
Jukko
Vargas
Corrales
Hernandez
Chavez
Castillo x 2
Corley
Bruseles
Judah
Baldo
Gatti
Mitchell
De La Hoya
Hatton
Marquez
Mosley
Ortiz
Cotto

Total: 20

Whitaker:

Mayweather
Ramirez x 2
Haugen
Pendleton
Nelson
Nazario
Chavez
Rivera x2
Hurtado
McGirt x 2
Cardona
Vazquez
Rodriguez
Jones
Pineda
Paez
Brazier

Total: 20

I'm going to check these othet statements too

Here's p4 p victories. Only includes guys that were on the list when they faced them:

Floyd:
Marquez #3
Hatton #8
Corrales #5
Mosley #3

Whitaker:
Chavez #1
McGirt#5
Nelson #7

Take that how you want it

These facts don't scream "Pernell >>>>>>>> Floyd and you're a nuthugger if you think otherwise ROFL herp derp" seems to me they're neck and neck but if you take into account Floyd's consistency and achievements (# of weightclasses he conquered, # of lineal champs he beat, staying undefeated while doing so) you have a case for ranking him slightly higher than Pernell.

[Larry the boss]

These facts don't scream "Pernell >>>>>>>> Floyd and you're a nuthugger if you think otherwise ROFL herp derp" seems to me they're neck and neck but if you take into account Floyd's consistency and achievements (# of weightclasses conquered, staying undefeated while doing so) you have a case for ranking him slightly higher than Pernell.

exactly......................people on here will insult you instead of debating with facts

most ranking have Pernell ranked 10-15.so if he is up there then so is Floyd

[bojangles1987]

These facts don't scream "Pernell >>>>>>>> Floyd and you're a nuthugger if you think otherwise ROFL herp derp" seems to me they're neck and neck but if you take into account Floyd's consistency and achievements (# of weightclasses he conquered, # of lineal champs he beat, staying undefeated while doing so) you have a case for ranking him slightly higher than Pernell.

Or you could take a look at the names on that list and see that Whitaker beat decisively better competition. Just something to throw out there.

[Larry the boss]

Or you could take a look at the names on that list and see that Whitaker beat decisively better competition. Just something to throw out there.

better comp based on what???cause we are listing the names and rankings at the time and im not seeing that at all

[SkillspayBills]

Now we are having a nice healthy debate.

[Kagami Taiga]

its one thing to say floyd's resume is better than pernell. thats cool, say it and back it up. its when u start backing it up with ******ity that ppl wil start making fun of u.

[bojangles1987]

better comp based on what???cause we are listing the names and rankings at the time and im not seeing that at all

See this is why your thread turned to sh**. You're honestly looking at the names on both sides and not seeing that Whitaker beat better fighters?

[Light_Speed]

And by the way on paper sweet pea drew with Chavez so he only beat 19 champs to Floyd's 20. It'll probably be 22-23 by the time he retires.