who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker

[Doctor_Tenma]

I still have to go with Floyd man he has just accomplished so much more and his longevity and consistency

No getting through to you then...

[-Hyperion-]

cant believe its this close...smh....Pernell...

[-PBP-]

Yeah I seen the Fenech fights, don't know if I can say Nelson was at his best at LW, still a great win for Whitaker nonetheless. Yeah that I saw, only that I fail to see how he was inducted.

Yeah that shocked me too. I just remember he had a few fights with Pazienza.

[Larry the boss]

cant believe its this close...smh....Pernell...

why wouldnt it be?

[SkillspayBills]

Ramirez - hall of fame
Haugen - hall of fame
Chavez - hall of fame
Nelson - hall of fame

All of these guys were at their best when Whitaker fought them.

Then you have:

McGirt - p4p ranked fighter by ring magazine
Vazquez- undefeated champion who went on to beay Winky Wright
Rivera x 2 - undefeated champion at the time

10 years from now Floyd will have more HOF's (actual inductees) in his resume than Whitaker. That's a fact.

[TX_BOXNG]

whitaker, dude fought real prime fighters, now days is about the fight with less risk n more money, back then it was to see who was the best, i think floyd is or was more skilled, but whitaker fought some of the best around his time win or lose

[Roman Moreno]

10 years from now Floyd will have more HOF's (actual inductees) in his resume than Whitaker. That's a fact.

10 years from now Pac will have more HOF's(actual inductees) in his resume than Leonard. That's a fact.

[-PBP-]

10 years from now Floyd will have more HOF's (actual inductees) in his resume than Whitaker. That's a fact.

Who?....I guess your thinking:

Mosley
De La Hoya
Marquez
Cotto
Hatton
Castillo

All 6 of them are not sure shot hall of famers. Boxigscene writers don't even have Hatton on there.

Plus, you have to look at when Floyd fought:

Mosley. - long overdue
De la Hoya - long overdue
Cotto - long overdue
Hatton - undefeated but struggled heavily with Collazo


And its not Floyds fault they didn't happen. But I'm not getting into arguments about wht fights didn't happen. They just didn't.

And yes he fought Mosley was ranked #3 after the margarito w. But that's not the Mosley that Oscar fought in their first matchup. Plus what have Mosley and Margarito done since then?

You can't just look at two sheets of paper and count statistics. I'm posting all this shyt so you can look at what's behind the numbers.

[RichCCFC]

Chavez win (its a win) >>>> all Mayweather's wins

[Larry the boss]

10 years from now floyd will have more hof's (actual inductees) in his resume than whitaker. That's a fact.

yep.......................