Roy Jones' Legacy: He beat those 18 World Champions....

[niallcollins]

roy was a beast when at 168

[-PBP-]

T/S must've forgot

[D4thincarnation]

[raskat]

ah ok you're trolling. whew you had me going there for a moment too. you're talents should be commended not criticized!

Extremely false.

Michalczewski has something like 20 title defences at light heavyweight. Toney hasnt done anything similar. Anbody who ranks James Toney higher than Michalczewski is a joke. Period
Im sick of these "James Toney is soo great" trolls. I also love how everybody says Max Schmeling was greater than the Klitschkos just cause he beat Joe Louis once. And these pple only say that to discredit the Klitschkos. The Klitschkos dominated for many years in their division while Schmeling lost more of his big fights than he won. Schmeling became world champ after a foul.
same with James Toney: he didnt do what Michalczewski did and anybody who says anything different is a clown.
Joe Louis is the greatest ever cause he has 25 title defences and Michalczewski is a bum cause he has 20 title defences?
Louis is american and Michalczewski isnt. Thats why some clowns come here and say Toney has a higher ATG ranking than Michalczewski. what a joke that is

[IMDAZED]

Michalczewski has something like 20 title defences at light heavyweight. Toney hasnt done anything similar. Anbody who ranks James Toney higher than Michalczewski is a joke. Period
Im sick of these "James Toney is the soo great" trolls. I also love how everybody says Max Schmeling was greater than the Klitschkos just cause he beat Joe Louis once. And these pple only say that to discredit the Klitschkos. The Klitschkos dominated for many years in their division while Schmeling lost more of his big fights than he won. Schmeling became world champ after a foul.
same with James Toney: he didnt do what Michalczewski did and anybody who says anything different is a clown.
Joe Louis is the greatest ever cause he has 25 title defences and Michalczewski is a bum cause he has 20 title defences?
Louis is american and Michalczewski isnt. Thats why some clowns come here and say Toney has a higher ATG ranking than Michalczewski. what a joke that is

Please list the names on Dariusz' title defenses. Much the same way you did Roy. I want to see the people he beat that make him so great.

[raskat]

Please list the names on Dariusz' title defenses. Much the same way you did Roy. I want to see the people he beat that make him so great.

James Toney didnt even beat Tiberi. Needed a gift decision. I already made my thread for today. How about you making a thread in which you break down Toney's career compared to Michalczewski's?
That would be fun

[dan_cov]

You could nitpick any fighters record.
Michalzweski? Michaelzweski's best wins was mainly guys coming off brutal K.O losses to Roy.

I agree Dariusz is maybe underrated especially on here but in no way does he rank over James Toney in terms of anything let alone Roy.

[dan_cov]

James Toney didnt even beat Tiberi. Needed a gift decision. I already made my thread for today. How about you making a thread in which you break down Toney's career compared to Michalczewski's?
That would be fun

Toneys TKO win over Holyfield >> Michaelzweski's whole resume.

[raskat]

Toneys TKO win over Holyfield >> Michaelzweski's whole resume.

LOL. This is the comment of the year. James Toney TKO's a 40 year old, totally shot Evander Holyfield and that is Toney's best win?

[BattlingNelson]

I choose to look past the resume and focus on his in ring ability.

For that reason alone, I rank him as an ATG and Hall of Famer.

I guess its possible to rate boxers based on wouldas, couldas and shouldas like you do, but I personally prefer rankings based on actual acheivements.