Comments Thread For: Months Overdue: BoxingScene's Pound-for Pound Update

[rethinkcommon]

A well thought out list. Much better than any I have seen in recent times.

[-PANDA-]

cotto should be on the list because unlike some of the champions that did make the list he has been active and has been impressive enough to warrant the number one spot at jmw

moreno is an odd entry...though he's a good fighter, the quality of his opponents isnt as high as some of the other fighters listed. one could possibly make a point of him beating darchinyan, but vic simply hasnt won a fight of note since beating mijares and arce which he did 3 years ago

mares has the edge on moreno based on the quality of opponents they've faced recently but it he isnt p4p top 10 material either...

[v.cassiusali@ya]

i don't know why hopkins was at #7...perhaps boxingscene wanted to appease the crying-old-man...

[Jam Jars]

Based from this latest BS PFP Ranking,
Pacman's last opponent and the next one, are more credible since they are among top ten!

Pacman vs Bradley is then much better than Mayweather Jr vs Cotto, because Cotto isn't rank among the top ten.

Yep and beating Donaire would be more impressive than beating Wlad.

[Bushbaby]

So they admit that Pacman's victory over the lightweight Marquez was hotly debated, yet somehow he still sits at #1?? When the fight right before that they chose a shot Sugar Shane?? Ok.

[Jam Jars]

So they admit that Pacman's victory over the lightweight Marquez was hotly debated, yet somehow he still sits at #1?? When the fight right before that they chose a shot Sugar Shane?? Ok.

I think they feel sorry for Pac because when he drops off the top spot he's never getting it back.

[New England]

do you guys know how to score afight?


marquez didn't lose to pacquiao

i dont give a damn what the judges, boxrec, michael buffer has to say abotu the records


marquez beat pacquiao

mayweather
marquez
ward
pacquiao
martinez
donaire
wladimir

and then it drops the hell off. vitali used to be up there in that tier, but he looked awful in his last fight and his gigantic body is deteriorating before our eyes.

[junior gong]

There is a few sore bot bots in here.

[Rapid Counter]

I think they feel sorry for Pac because when he drops off the top spot he's never getting it back.

Your Usman avi made me laugh out loud

[New England]

and hopkins!


you have got to be joking...


props to moreno

resume wise he doesnt deserve it, but H2H the guy is a flippin nightmare style. i could watch him box all day. tons of craft