Prime Hall of Fame fighters in Floyd resume?

[Walt Liquor]

floyd has a couple of wins over VERRRRY suspect hof'ers in their prime....

period.

if hatton gets in the HOF, I will stop following boxing. what a joke.

[Reloaded]

you are a straight fool if you think those 3 should be hof

Go and have a look who is in the HOF , there are quite a few in that those guys would beat .

And there is not a fighter on Manny resume that Floyd would not beat and beat rather easy , you guys apply to much to labels rather than actually look at what it stands for .

[Walt Liquor]

Go and have a look who is in the HOF , there are quite a few in that those guys would beat .

And there is not a fighter on Manny resume that Floyd would not beat and beat rather easy , you guys apply to much to labels rather than actually look at what it stands for .

How do you know they would beat them? I understand that fantasy fight types like yourself would feel that way, too bad fantasy fights don't count for shi t.

What would floyd have done with, say shane's resume?

talk to me when you live in the real world

[Walt Liquor]

Go and have a look who is in the HOF , there are quite a few in that those guys would beat .

And there is not a fighter on Manny resume that Floyd would not beat and beat rather easy , you guys apply to much to labels rather than actually look at what it stands for .

I agree that floyd should be in the fantasy fight HOF.

[turbotime]

How do you know they would beat them? I understand that fantasy fight types like yourself would feel that way, too bad fantasy fights don't count for shi t.

What would floyd have done with, say shane's resume?

talk to me when you live in the real world

The only fighters I see Floyd having a hard time with are the 2000 version of Oscar and the 2001 Forrest. No shame in that.

[Walt Liquor]

The only fighters I see Floyd having a hard time with are the 2000 version of Oscar and the 2001 Forrest. No shame in that.

i hear you, can't wait until they judge ATG on how you may have done vs other HOF fighters....

[4Corners]

you are a straight fool if you think those 3 should be hof

That'd be pretty true if other guys hadn't gotten in so easily, mainly Kostya Tszyu, Barry McGuigan, and Brian Mitchell.

Tszyu's wins: Jake Rodriguez, Roger Mayweather, Hugo Pineda, Jan Bergman, Rafael Ruelas, Miguel Gonzalez, Julio Cesar Chavez (way past his prime), Sharmba Mitchell, Oktay Urkal, Zab Judah, and Jesse Leija.

McGuigan's wins: Eusebio Pedroza, Bernard Taylor, and Danilo Cabrera.

Mitchell's wins: Daniel Londas, Jackie Beard, Jim McDonnell, Tony Lopez, and Frankie Mitchell.

Those guys are in already.

Corrales' wins: Roberto Garcia, Derrick Gainer, Justin Juuko, Angel Manfredy, Joel Casamayor, Acelino Freitas, and Jose Luis Castillo.

Castillo's wins: Jorge Paez, Cesar Bazan, Stevie Johnston, Juan Lazcano, Joel Casamayor, Julio Diaz, and Diego Corrales. Should also have a win over Floyd Mayweather probably.

Hatton's wins: Kostya Tszyu, Carlos Maussa, Luis Collazo, Juan Urango, Jose Luis Castillo (past his prime though), Juan Lazcano, and Paulie Malignaggi.

Genaro's wins: Daniel Londas, Raul Perez, Jorge Ramirez, Jorge Paez, Azumah Nelson, Anatoly Alexandrov, Carlos Hernandez, and Carlos Gerena.

When comparing the resume's of the guys in to the guys who "don't deserve to be in", it's interesting. I'll take Corrales and Castillo's best wins at the very least equal to Tszyu's, and far better than McGuigan or Mitchell. And Genaro and Hatton are clearly superior to Mitchell and McGuigan's resume's.

[turbotime]

i hear you, can't wait until they vote for HOF on how you may have done vs other HOF fighters....

Floyd is a first ballot HOF'er, fantasy match ups or not.

[Walt Liquor]

Floyd is a first ballot HOF'er, fantasy match ups or not.

i edited my post, of course floyd is 1st ballot, he just never beat a prime hof'er

[4Corners]

i edited my post, of course floyd is 1st ballot, he just never beat a prime hof'er

If Tszyu, Mitchell, and McGuigan are in based on their resume's.....why not Diego Coralles or Jose Luis Castillo with their resume??? Even Richy Hatton and Genaro Hernandez have far better resumes than Brian Mitchell and Barry McGuigan. S**t, Zab Judah has a better resume than Mitchell and McGuigan.