Better win??? Duran over Barkley or Floyd over Sergio???

[MJ223]

Assuming May fights and beats Sergio at 160 which is the better win???

Simple ?.......

Thoughts???

[Young Money]

Interesting question, what do you see it as MJ223?

[Reloaded]

Sergio gives Barkley a boxing lesson .

[4Corners]

Sergio Martinez

[Larry the boss]

both=great wins

[MJ223]

Interesting question, what do you see it as MJ223?

I favor Duran..... Duran was at a bigger size disadvantage facing Barkley then Floyd would be with Sergio..... Barkley was younger had more power and was a favorite to win..... Idk how the oddsmakers would set the odds for a Floyd Sergio fight but I doubt if it happened Floyd would be a massive underdog

Not to discount the Pavlik win for Sergio but Barkley has Hearns on his resume.... Duran also KD'ed Barkley something I doubt Floyd would be able to do with Sergio

Add that to the fact Duran started off at super bantam while Floyd started off at 130..... And I lean towards Duran

[MJ223]

both=great wins

Very true Larry.... Just something that crossed my mind and I was wondering what my NSB fam thought about it.....

[bojangles1987]

Depend on how Floyd won. If he completely destroyed and embarrassed Sergio, I'd take him. Anything competitive, I go with Duran over Barkley.

[gauze]

I favor Duran..... Duran was at a bigger size disadvantage facing Barkley then Floyd would be with Sergio..... Barkley was younger had more power and was a favorite to win..... Idk how the oddsmakers would set the odds for a Floyd Sergio fight but I doubt if it happened Floyd would be a massive underdog

Not to discount the Pavlik win for Sergio but Barkley has Hearns on his resume.... Duran also KO'ed Barkley something I doubt Floyd would be able to do with Sergio

Add that to the fact Duran started off at super bantam while Floyd started off at 130..... And I lean towards Duran

duran won a split decision, he knocked barkley down in the 11th.

[MJ223]

duran won a split decision, he knocked barkley down in the 11th.

Thanks for pointing that out.... Spell check on my phone changed it from KD to KO'ed and I completely overlooked it.....