Comments Thread For: McGirt: Mayweather, Marquez - The True Greats of Our Era

[LeG00N]

I could agree with him to some extent. But they fought each other and Floyd is clearly the more superior boxer. If floyd is #1 and JMM is #2, then that just doesnt make any sense.

Im sorry to JMM fans but he'll only be #2 to me if he can clear out the WW division.

they didn't fight each other in a P4P scenario.
which makes your point invalid

and Floyd didn't even clear out the WW division

[Dempsey-Roll]

they didn't fight each other in a P4P scenario.
which makes your point invalid

and Floyd didn't even clear out the WW division

Did i mention in my post that floyd is #1 p4p??

[Scarab]

Did i mention in my post that floyd is #1 p4p??

Not on this site's P4P list: http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/view.php?pg=pound

[Biolink]

Marquez been kickin ass for a minute and has taken on all comers. Really gotta hand it to that man.

[Check_hooks]

McGirt is only half right. Those two are great but not truly great.

Marquez got kd by katsidas and lost to chris john and lost 3 times to Pac.

Floyd ducked and dodged and retired and sucker punched his way to where he is now. He is however the ATG when it comes to ducking and dodging.

The truly greats of our era are both Klits, BHop and Pac. This is in no particular order but if I had to put them in order I would put the fighter of the decade first and yall all know who that is.

[Chief2ndzOnly!]

War Mayweather!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[tlaloc]

Marquez & Mayweather are my fav fighters. They can't be touched when it comes to boxing skills and just way too smart in the ring... Alexis Arguello was also a great technician and a great person...

[thuggery]

Yup, Marquez and May at the top. How it has always been.

Marquez beat Pac 2 times for sure and 1 draw. As quoted by Bob Arum himself talking to Marquez after the 3rd fight "Don't take it personal, it's just business"

[RSBonos]

So the guy Marquez couldn't convincingly beat is not a great?

[thuggery]

8 rounds to 4 is convincing enough for me