Pound-for-Pound: The Fifty Greatest Boxers Of All-Time

[americanbot]

reberto duran is also too high..........top 4 fighter of ALL TIME?

[underoath777]

Really, no Tyson?

[ИATAS]

How is it bad logic? It's not bad logic at all. It's only natural people would select a higher number is it not?

you are mentally damaged man.

[Chups]

he included mayweather...

****...I didn't see that.....and no Pacman?.........well he's an idiot then. How is FMJ resume ever better than Pac?

[ИATAS]

****...I didn't see that.....and no Pacman?.........well he's an idiot then. How is FMJ resume ever better than Pac?

well, like you said the guy is an idiot.

[Mr. Fantastic]

It doesn't matter how many divisions you numskull it's about your resume and who you beat. Just like pac is an "8 division champ" but he didn't beat 8 of the best fighters, he's a four time lineal champ not 8. No one is going to give him tons of credit for beating david diaz & margarito.



Hopkins actually fought and beat every single #1 & 2 ranked fighter in the division while he was there while Calzaghe & Ottke can't say the same, in fact these two "all time greats" had 21 title defense each at the same time in the same weight division. How the hell does that even happen? It's embarrassing.

Pac is an 8 division champ and is considered AN ATG. Is he not?? He may not have 8 lineal championships but he has around 4 I think. Roy Jones is a perfect example, he seems to get much more credit than Pac considering he doesn't have anywhere near the 4 lineal championships Pac has.


I didn't call them ATGs, I said they don't get as much credit as others considering they defended their belts for a while. Not just anyone can do that though. Specially maintaining the same weight for years and years.

[Oxn]

How is it bad logic? It's not bad logic at all. It's only natural people would select a higher number is it not?

Mr Fantastic, your avatar is driving me nuts

[americanbot]

****...I didn't see that.....and no Pacman?.........well he's an idiot then. How is FMJ resume ever better than Pac?

how is reberto duran the top 4 greatest fighter of all time.

[IronDanHamza]

****...I didn't see that.....and no Pacman?.........well he's an idiot then. How is FMJ resume ever better than Pac?

He made the list in 2008 and to be honest back in 2008 pretty much no one considered Pacquaio to be greater than Mayweather.

So I imagine that's why he's not in the list. I'm sure he would be in it if he re-made it today.

[Mr. Fantastic]

you are mentally damaged man.

How am I mentally damaged if I exposed your flawed pathetic logic and favoritism in another thread. You're the one using polls from Boxingscene as your evidence but yet don't want to admit Calzaghe beat Hopkins considering there is plenty of polls from here to prove it.