Who has the better resume, Mayweather or Cotto???

[4Corners]

This is in response to the "Would Cotto be better than Floyd all-time if he beats Pacquiao" thread.

Miguel Cotto's notable resume:

2002: Justin Juuko (36-6-1)- W TKO5
2003: Cesar Bazan (39-5-1)- W TKO11
2003: Carlos Maussa (17-0)- W TKO8
2004: Victorian Sosa (37-3-2)- W TKO4
2004: Lovemore N'dou (38-6-1)- W UD12
2004: Kelson Pinto (21-0)- W TKO6
2004: Randall Bailey (28-4)- W TKO6
2005: Demarus Corley (29-3-1)- W TKO5
2005: Ricardo Torres (28-0)- W KO7
2006: Paulie Malignaggi (21-0)- W UD12
2006: Carlos Quintana (23-0)- W RTD5
2007: Zab Judah (34-4)- W TKO11
2007: Shane Mosley (44-4)- W UD12
2008: Antonio Margarito (36-5)- L TKO11
2009: Michael Jennings (34-1)- W TKO5
2009: Joshua Clottey (35-2)- W SD12
2009: Manny Pacquiao (49-3-2)- L TKO12
2010: Yuri Foreman (28-0)- W TKO9
2011: Ricardo Mayorga (29-7-1)- W TKO12
2011: Antonio Margarito (38-7)- W RTD10

Floyd Mayweather's notable resume:

1998: Genaro Hernandez (38-1-1)- W RTD8
1998: Angel Manfredy (25-2-1)- W TKO2
1999: Justin Juuko (33-2-1)- W KO9
1999: Carlos Gerena (34-2)- W RTD7
2000: Gregorio Vargas (40-6-1)- W UD12
2001: Diego Corrales (33-0)- W TKO10
2001: Carlos Hernandez (33-2-1)- W UD12
2001: Jesus Chavez (35-1)- W RTD9
2002: Jose Luis Castillo (45-4-1)- W UD12
2002: Jose Luis Castillo (46-5-1)- W UD12
2003: Victoriano Sosa (35-2-2)- W UD12
2003: Phillip N'dou (31-1)- W TKO7
2004: DeMarcus Corley (28-2-1)- W UD12
2005: Arturo Gatti (39-6)- W RTD6
2006: Zab Judah (34-3)- W UD12
2006: Carlos Baldomir (43-9-6)- W UD12
2007: Oscar De La Hoya (38-4)- W SD12
2007: Ricky Hatton (43-0)- W TKO10
2009: Juan Manuel Marquez (50-4-1)- W UD12
2010: Shane Mosley (46-5)- W UD12
2011: Victor Ortiz (29-2-2)- W KO4

What do YOU think???

[onechance87]

[EdMon917]

Mayweather is undefeated while Cotto has one clear loss and a tainted one by Margacheato. I don't think Cotto beats Manny in a rematch as well since they won't be fighting at Light Middleweight. Mayweather has the better resume of course.

[daggum]

cotto lives too far away to compare resumes with floyd.

[deliveryman]

Mayweather and it's not even close.

Floyd's run of:

Diego Corales
Carlos Hernandez
Jesus Chavez
Jose Luis Castillo x2

****s over Cotto's resume alone.

[JmH Reborn]

Mayweather is undefeated while Cotto has one clear loss and a tainted one by Margacheato. I don't think Cotto beats Manny in a rematch as well since they won't be fighting at Light Middleweight. Mayweather has the better resume of course.

Mayweather has a better resume because he [Cotto] lost to Pacquaio?

Genius

[JmH Reborn]

Mayweather and it's not even close.

A comparison of their resume as in the OP makes it very close.

Mayweather's best win is Chico

Ho-Hum

[Guest]

Mayweather and it's not even close.

Floyd's run of:

Diego Corales
Carlos Hernandez
Jesus Chavez
Jose Luis Castillo x2

****s over Cotto's resume alone.

Too bad he never fought the best at welter, while Cotto took his lunps and fought all..

Maybe Cotto should've retired or fought Baldomir to be equal.

Mayweather's retirement and ducking of Margarito gets zero points with me.

At least Cotto fought Murderer's row in their prime.

[-Deal With It-]

A comparison of their resume as in the OP makes it very close.

Mayweather's best win is Chico

Ho-Hum

Only to the untrained eye of a boxrec/wikipedia scholar

[puga]

overalll it's floyd's..but cotto's resume is better at common weighclasses...40, 47, 54...