Who has the better resume, Mayweather or Cotto???

[savorduhflavor]

.......And this is the sole reason Cotto gets hate on this board.

[GrandpaBernard]

.......And this is the sole reason Cotto gets hate on this board.

because his groupies blindly vote for him?

[Kagami Taiga]

Too bad he never fought the best at welter, while Cotto took his lunps and fought all..

Maybe Cotto should've retired or fought Baldomir to be equal.

Mayweather's retirement and ducking of Margarito gets zero points with me.

At least Cotto fought Murderer's row in their prime.

thats bull****.

[deliveryman]

A comparison of their resume as in the OP makes it very close.

Mayweather's best win is Chico

Ho-Hum

Which given the circumstances being Diego was ranked highly on people's P4P list, was undefeated and had a ridiculously high KO%. And Floyd completely schooled him and floored him 5 times. Floyd was even the betting underdog going in.

That alone is better than anything Cotto has done.

Oh and here's a fun fact: Floyd has been the lineal champ of 3 separate weight classes. Cotto - 0.

[EdMon917]

Mayweather has a better resume because he [Cotto] lost to Pacquaio?

Genius

Mayweather has no losses. Cotto has two. One of the losses is by Manny Pacquiao, someone who Mayweather will probably beat if they fight. To me it's not who you fight, it's who you beat. Cotto has good names on his record but he has been beaten. Mayweather has just about as many good names and he has beaten all of them. Does that make sense?

[Guest]

overalll it's floyd's..but cotto's resume is better at common weighclasses...40, 47, 54...

thats bull****.

Ok who did mayweather fight in 2004? in 2008?

No one.


Cotto fought Margarito, why didn't Mayweather want any of that?

Was it because of retirement or something?

Enlighten me.

[Kagami Taiga]

Ok who did mayweather fight in 2004? in 2008?

No one.


Cotto fought Margarito, why didn't Mayweather want any of that?

Was it because of retirement or something?

Enlighten me.

lmao, so now one fighter constitutes murderers row??? gotcha.

[daggum]

Mayweather has no losses. Cotto has two. One of the losses is by Manny Pacquiao, someone who Mayweather will probably beat if they fight. To me it's not who you fight, it's who you beat. Cotto has good names on his record but he has been beaten. Mayweather has just about as many good names and he has beaten all of them. Does that make sense?

cotto's only been beaten by guys mayweather ducked. what a coincidence.....

[Guest]

lmao, so now one fighter constitutes murderers row??? gotcha.

Who constitutes murderer's row in the Mayweatther pantheon at this time?

Baldomir?

DeLaHoya?

Hatton?

Corley?

A vacation?

[Hougigo]

Mayweather IMO.
I did find it funny that Cotto fought somebody who looked like the Dark Night Joker