List your ATG's since the 80's

[turbotime]

Sweet Pea
Lennox
Delahoya
Jones Jr
Holyfield
Mayweather
Pacquiao
Hopkins
Morales
Barrera
Ricardo Lopez
JMM

[Jedi Vader]

Not an ATG in my book.

Bro are you facking serious with that assertion or is this 2012's earliest April fool??

[daggum]

You forgot felix sturm.

he has 2 losses. how can he be an all time great?

[Cardinal Buck]

I'm gonna take the controversial opinion and say that Naseem Hamed is an ATG. He brought the spotlight to 122 and 126 and had a pretty good run there, although somewhat short-lived and not a bullet-proof list of opposition. It's popular to dismiss his entire career because of an 8-4 decision loss to Barrera when Hamed was basically disinterested in boxing, but I'm not going to. My point is that a discussion of the best 122-126 ever on a given night should include Hamed...so I'm gonna say he slides onto the ATG list, conceding that there have been lesser fighters with better resumes.

[Kagami Taiga]

I'm gonna take the controversial opinion and say that Naseem Hamed is an ATG. He brought the spotlight to 122 and 126 and had a pretty good run there, although somewhat short-lived and not a bullet-proof list of opposition. It's popular to dismiss his entire career because of an 8-4 decision loss to Barrera when Hamed was basically disinterested in boxing, but I'm not going to. My point is that a discussion of the best 122-126 ever on a given night should include Hamed...so I'm gonna say he slides onto the ATG list, conceding that there have been lesser fighters with better resumes.

no way. hes a hofer yes. atg? no way.

[RubenSonny]

Sweet Pea
Roy Jones Jr
BHop
Pac
Floyd (i now think I finally have him as ATG after his last win)
Lennox
Evander
MAB
el Terrible

Jmm borderline

You really think Lennox is greater than Marquez?

[IronDanHamza]

Bro are you facking serious with that assertion or is this 2012's earliest April fool??

I'm absolutely serious. And I'm not alone in thinking that either.

Lennox Lewis is not an ATG, IMO.

Maybe at Heavyweight he's an ATG. And that's still somewhat argubale depending on one's criteria.

[Walt Liquor]

You really think Lennox is greater than Marquez?

if marquez would have bulled his way into the morales/marquez/pac triumverant earlier and not had such poor career management (like getting back with pac sooner), I'd have him in for sure.

I agonize about JMM's place all time. If he would have caught a break on any of those fights vs Pac, there'd be no doubt. I had him winning the first fight.

as far as signature wins vs prime hof/atg's, he's a little lacking. I also wish he would have avenged either of his losses to norwood or john.

[Walt Liquor]

although I should give him extra extra credit for shutting down and beating up smoke gainer.

[IMDAZED]

Azumah Nelson