Could MAB, Morales or Marquez beat Mayweather @ 130 Lbs?

[megas30]

Posted the full length original article, but I'm sure it's all part of the inexplicable elaborate hoax. Like I said before, it's just sparring. Spadafora, Lamont Peterson, and looks like now Erik Morales all beat Floyd up in sparring... but that was only 3-4 rounds or so. If Mayweather-Judah, May-Shane, and a bunch of other Floyd fights had been only 3-4 rounds, he'd have a ton of Ls on his record. He's a notoriously slow starter and has had some rough starts but usually cruises to wins once he gets his bearings straight.

No need to catch feelings over sparring.

Why are we now just hearing this from Morales, when he's rabidly campaigning for fight with Floyd? And to the TS, NONE, no one wanted to fight Floyd at 130 and 140.

[mikemurni]

*****s still hang up of what Floyd woulda coulda and shoulda, instead of what he had done..lol...
Morons...

[turbotime]

Is there any way to edit the poll to show open voting? Wasn't aware of that option....

[D4thincarnation]

Would any of those 3 have beaten Floyd at Junior Lightweight? The weights where Pac beat them?

All 3 of them are much superior to anything Floyd has faced at 130lbs

[Larry the boss]

no,no and no,all get stopped

[D4thincarnation]

Morales and Barrera were both visibly past their prime at 130.

Is that why for 3 year at least 1 of them were ranked in the top 2 the division.

Maybe that shows how weak of a division Floyd ruled over if past primes super-batams can be ranked number in the division then.

[IronDanHamza]

Is that why for 3 year at least 1 of them were ranked in the top 2 the division.

And? What's your point?

Did you read "They were shot at 130?" or do you not think a past prime fighter can be ranked #1 or #2 in a division?

Past prime Barrera and Morales >>> The majority of fighters during their stay at 130.

This is the problem with this website. People just read what they want to see.

I merely said 'Barrera and Morales were visibly past their prime when they were at 130"

Are you denying that? Are you going to claim they weren't past their prime at 130?

And I said NOTHING else, other than that clear, black and white statment. So your post has no point or relevance.

Maybe that shows how weak of a division Floyd ruled over if past primes super-batams can be ranked number in the division then.

Maybe it does. Again, is there a point?

I don't think anyone is going to try and argue that 130 when Mayweather was there was an up and down stacked division.

It was a solid division.

Although, the fact past prime ATG's were #1 or #2 at peroids during their stay there doesn't indicate it's weak, really.

[D4thincarnation]

And? What's your point?

Did you read "They were shot at 130?" or do you not think a past prime fighter can be ranked #1 or #2 in a division?

Past prime Barrera and Morales >>> The majority of fighters during their stay at 130.

This is the problem with this website. People just read what they want to see.

I merely said 'Barrera and Morales were visibly past their prime when they were at 130"

Are you denying that? Are you going to claim they weren't past their prime at 130?

And I said NOTHING else, other than that clear, black and white statment. So your post has no point or relevance.




Maybe it does. Again, is there a point?

I don't think anyone is going to try and argue that 130 when Mayweather was there was an up and down stacked division.

It was a solid division.

Although, the fact past prime ATG's were #1 or #2 at peroids during their stay there doesn't indicate it's weak, really.

Past prime, what does exactly does that mean? Not at their best. So Pacquiao is past prime since after the Cotto fight then.

Barera improved much from the 1st time he faced Pacquiao from the 2nd time he face Pacquiao. But according to you he was further past him prime.

Bit of a contradiction there.

[ThePrince]

Why are we now just hearing this from Morales, when he's rabidly campaigning for fight with Floyd? And to the TS, NONE, no one wanted to fight Floyd at 130 and 140.

Don't know, don't care. And he hasn't been 'rabidly campaigning' for anything, just mentioned that Richard Schaefer/GBP spoke to him about the possibility of a fight with Floyd in May and he thinks he'd give a good match. If anything, he's been more vocal about getting a rematch with Manny.

Either way, the OP asked a hypothetical question about how three Mexican legends would fare against Floyd at 130. Those fights never happened and will never happen, and the only thing remotely resembling any one of those matchups was Morales' account of their sparring session. According to Morales, he got the best of Floyd- had him reeling and groggy.

Both Terrible and Floyd were 24-25 at the time, Floyd was at 130, Erik was getting ready for a fight with Kelley at 126. So they were the same age and I assume roughly the same weight. Terrible says he gave Floyd the business.

Has no bearing on an actual fight because 12 round championship match =/= sparring. But it's the closest to that fantasy match that we'll get. If you want to believe Morales made the whole thing up like some dunces I won't name and that helps you sleep at night, go nuts.

[MrClutch85]

No Floyd was a beast at 130