who's greater joe calzaghe or winky wright

[J-Smooth]

you guys are making some great arguments....its close but imo winky edges him with a better resume its very close tho

[IronDanHamza]

At least we agree it's a UD lol.

I didn't ever disagree to a UD.

It's just not a significantly clear one.

One you coul argue was 'reasonably close' despite the winner getting a relatively clear victory, despite not being convincing.

[IMDAZED]

I didn't ever disagree to a UD.

It's just not a significantly clear one.

One you coul argue was 'reasonably close' despite the winner getting a relatively clear victory, despite not being convincing.

Nah I see it 8-4, 9-3. Don't see Winky in this one although he has his moments.

[Joeyzagz]

you guys are making some great arguments....its close but imo winky edges him with a better resume its very close tho

Winky is a never was.

[IronDanHamza]

Nah I see it 8-4, 9-3. Don't see Winky in this one although he has his moments.

Absolutely no way in hell is it 9-3.

[Joeyzagz]

When Winky reaches 21 consecutive title defenses give me a call.

[Dave Rado]

After Mayweather's retirement (after Hatton fight), Calzaghe was considered the P4P number 1 (Ring magazine had him at number 2 behind Pac, but most purists had Calzaghe at number 1). That speaks volumes in itself.

What have you been drinking? I want some.

The Ring never had Calzaghe higher than #3, and nor did any serious boxing rankings.

[starjammer]

What have you been drinking? I want some.

The Ring never had Calzaghe higher than #3, and nor did any serious boxing rankings.

The list provided by and compiled by Ring Magazine (thering-online.com) are listed from Top placement to the 10th placement. At the bottom of the list we've provided a link to the Top fighters as ranked by Ring Magazine for each Weight Division. You can Check out the Top fighters for each division for the period ending June 9, 2008.

For Period Ended June 9, 2008
POUND-FOR-POUND Top 10
1.) MANNY PACQUIAO
2.) JOE CALZAGHE
3.) JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
4.) BERNARD HOPKINS
5.) ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
6.) MIGUEL COTTO
7.) KELLY PAVLIK
8.) CRISTIAN MIJARES
9.) RAFAEL MARQUEZ
10.) IVAN CALDERON.

[IMDAZED]

Absolutely no way in hell is it 9-3.

8-4 is significant enough for me.

[Dave Rado]

When Winky reaches 21 consecutive title defenses give me a call.

Trust you to lower the tone of this thread.

By your reckoning Zsolt Erdei is obviously an ATG.

Standard of opposition is far more important than number of defences.