***OFFICIAL POLL*** Who is better overall? MAYORGA or MARGARITO?

[jrosales13]

you said he used PEDs... THAT IS NOT FACT... that is your bull***** opinion



THE FACT is that he got caught with diuretics, and thats it




you used the 'PEDs' card to defend allegations of margarito possibly using plaster thruout his resume.... THE FACT is that he was suspended for his involvement in illegal wraps, and THAT FACT will cast shadows on all his prior wins FOREVER




youre a trashy ****, and thats that

So again we are suppose to believe that either Clottey and P-Will are SUPERHUMAN. Or for some reason. Margarito who plastered up for his entire resume chose not to for Perez, Santos, Clottey, and P-Will? WTF?

Of course you can't get caught using PED's while having a masking agent. Exactly why he used a masking agent.

The FACT is Mayorga took a banned substance that benefited him. Which was illegal, therefor he cheated. And, we don't know how long that went on.

Now take that little ma'am.

[jrosales13]

"nowhere close"? How the **** is it "nowhere close" you goofy bastard.

Name Margarito's 5 best wins so we can have a good laugh.

Also, could you imagine Margarito trying to fight Trinidad @ MIDDLEWEIGHT? It would result in utter hilarity

I will name Marg 5 best wins and then you name me Mayorga's. But, why 5 and not lest say 10? Because, barely only 5 can be on Mayorga list?

1. Cotto
2. Clottey
3. Cintron
4. Lewis
5. Martinez.

First of all lets not act like if Tito was a beast at MW or even a prime at that time. Or even active. Lets not pretend that.

But, you might be right...And, Marg probably couldn't **** with that version of Tito...But, neither could Mayorga and that's been proven. So your point?

Now name Mayorga 5 best wins so we can have a good laugh. Go......

[Deal With It]

I will name Marg 5 best wins and then you name me Mayorga's. But, why 5 and not lest say 10? Because, barely only 5 can be on Mayorga list?

1. Cotto
2. Clottey
3. Cintron
4. Lewis
5. Martinez.

1. Forrest (Lineal/Ring champ, undefeated, coming off 2 victories over the #1 p4p)
2. Vargas (greater fighter than anybody in Marg's top 5)
3. Piccirillo (Win over a ranked Junior-Middleweight, something Margarito's never acheived)
4. Lewis (Top 3 Welterweight, undefeated at the time)
5. Doesn't need a 5, he beat Forrest twice, showing it wasn't a fluke.

Like i said, more or less even.

But, you might be right...And, Marg probably couldn't **** with that version of Tito...But, neither could Mayorga and that's been proven. So your point?

That they're more or less the same caliber of fighter, duuuuuuuuuh.

[Darkstar]

So in other words Don King said no to the fight? Thank you for agreeing with me.

They didnt say no to anything, it wasnt even a issue in the real world.


Fight a pound for pound ranked fighter, top of the divsion, on the main event of HBO card with 3 belts on the line, for 1,000,000$.


Or fight some guy named Margarito who is maybe top 8 in the divison for $250,000.

[jrosales13]

1. Forrest (Lineal/Ring champ, undefeated, coming off 2 victories over the #1 p4p)
2. Vargas (greater fighter than anybody in Marg's top 5)
3. Piccirillo (Win over a ranked Junior-Middleweight, something Margarito's never acheived)
4. Lewis (Top 3 Welterweight, undefeated at the time)
5. Doesn't need a 5, he beat Forrest twice, showing it wasn't a fluke.

Like i said, more or less even.



That they're more or less the same caliber of fighter, duuuuuuuuuh.

Vargas is a greater fighter than anyone on Marg top 5? That version of Vargas? Again like I said casual fans who didn't follow the sport closely at the time. Will look at names. And, not know that more importantly than who is when.

And, Picirillo is weaker than anyone of Marg top 10 wins.

And, LOL @ not needing a 5

That doesn't prove one way or the other if they're the same caliber of fighter.

[jrosales13]

They didnt say no to anything, it wasnt even a issue in the real world.


Fight a pound for pound ranked fighter, top of the divsion, on the main event of HBO card with 3 belts on the line, for 1,000,000$.


Or fight some guy named Margarito who is maybe top 8 in the divison for $250,000.

The offer was there TWICE. Chose Spinks over Marg as well...Of course you going to tell me how much greater fighting Spinks that that time was. But, again that is neither here nor there. Like I said King said no to the fight. Which you even admit...Thank you for agreeing with me.

[FrenchDeLaHoya]

marg next fight exactly. where he'll lose

[JPRINCEOFBOXING]

would've been a great fight but i truelly think margarito's body shots would've stoped him inside of 8 rounds mayorga has a wild style throws punches from diffrent directions but i think that margarito knows were to put his punches and also you gotta remember this styles make fight's and i think that mayorga would try to punch with margarito and that would be his down fall. the pressure that margarito would've put on mayorga would of break mayorga down .... but honestly i think that this fight would've been fight of the year if it would've been made...

[Deal With It]

Vargas is a greater fighter than anyone on Marg top 5? That version of Vargas?

Yes, THAT version of Vargas, fighting that version of Mayorga who was coming off a string of KO losses himself. Not better than Cotto, but better than everybody else on his resume fa'sho.

And, Picirillo is weaker than anyone of Marg top 10 wins.

Complete bullshit.

Margarito to this day, still hasn't had a victory over a ranked Junior-Middleweight, Mayorga at least has one.

And BTW, it completely slipped my mind that Margarito had a victory over Sergio Martinez, so yeah, you win.

[Darkstar]

Overall Mayorga is better imo. Mayorga got into the game late so he didnt have the best longevity. But prime for prime, he was overall faster then Margarito, better handspeed and hit harder. Not only that but a much better chin as well. A 37 year old Mosley KOed him easily at 147. It took one of the best p4p punching hitters of the last 20 years to finally crack Mayorga, and he gave him free shots to do it. A 31 year old Trinidad at middleweight is power that Margarito has never felt. If Shane could do that to him at 147, at 160 Trinidad would have toyed with him and KOed him in no less then 3.


A really past prime 37 year old Mayorga and prime 31 year old Margarito fought Mosley just 4 months apart. Mayorga put on a 10 times better performance then Margarito did. With that you could also say Mayorga was a better boxer if need be.