Comments Thread For: The Update: BoxingScene.com Pound-for-Pound Top Ten

[Furn]

Pac should be 1 because its P4P and he is a small guy beating much bigger guys. Sure Floyd would most likely beat him although i give Pac a good chance.

For floyd to achieve what Pac has he would have to beat a Froch or Ward at a catchweight of 164 or so. He's never beaten a much bigger guy.

Also why does Bradley get a mention and Khan doesn't ? Khan should be pushing top 10.

[sd southpaw]

Such a bad list, c'mon bscene!

P4P:

Mayweather
Pacquiao
Martinez
Donaire
Marquez
Ward
Gamboa
W. Klitschko
Wonjongkam

not bad, i havent seen enough of wonjongkam i might have replaced him with froch but good list

[Deal With It]

Outrageously shitty rankings.

Cliff Rold is rapidly climbing up the biggest ******s in boxing journalism p4p rankings, only trailing Michael Marley and reigning p4p king Scoop Malinowski.

[turbotime]

not bad, i havent seen enough of wonjongkam i might have replaced him with froch but good list

Thanks! Yeah a case can be made for either Bradley, Froch, Khan, etc. for Wonjon's place but as it stands I guess I'll conform to having him on there a little bit

[B.R!ghteous]

Sergio shouldn't even be in the top 10. Barker's resume and performance alone almost drops him out of the top 20. Pac and May should not be 1 & 2. Noth have had horrible recent outings and with Pac's delay, both have dodged each other to end the dispute. JMM righfully at 3. 2 Super Middle's and neither one's name is Lucian Bute - NICE! B-Hop should be higher in the rankings.

By the way, JMM didn't fight JMM in his last 5 outings. Typo should say Pacquiao.

[PacquiaoATG]

The pictures tells the story...




Cry *****S/FLOYDIOTS

[Kokina88]

Marquez 1 of the greatest ever
not sure why he was dropped so far down he only lost 2 mayweather
and i think the marquez mayweather fights should influence the 1 and the 2 making mayweather the #1

[Pactards GTFO]

If anything they only put the PED user up top because they wanted to feel edgy and cool and be different than all the other credible places that have the true #1 p4p at the top, Money May

[sd southpaw]

lmao and the here come the haters that don't know **** about boxing

Pac looked great against Marquez and Mosley. He didn't knock them out but he dominated them in every conceivable way that boxing fights are supposed to be scored. And neither of them have EVER been knocked out before and they ran for dear life so how you gonna hold that against Pac?

And who else fought 2 first ballot HOFers in 7 months? No one would even dream of doing that except Pac.

I also completely agree with Froch being ahead of Andre "I get cut with headgear and pillows on" Ward

The only problem I have with the list is BHop shouldn't be on there after that embarrasing display he put on against Dawson. Wlad should be there and Vitali/Khan should be there.

check hooker you dont know **** about boxing. win lose or draw pac didnt dominate marquez.get dudes *** out yo mouth homie its gittin embarrasing.and for you to speak on ward for being cut in sparring shows you probably never been in the ring before.

[nujabes77]

im actually glad... this means money may is the underdog