IF Floyd retires 45-0 with wins over Khan,Manny and Martinez to close it out

[Hamaru]

If he beat all three and retired, I'd say he would be in the top 3 ATG...maybe 2nd after ALI.

[Barry Halls]

you guys are insane. Seriously.

Top10? top5? top2????

If we compare this hypothetical resume to a guy I'm sure most of you know, Ray Leonard.
Now Ray is a top10 ATG. Not even he has a strong case for being top5, let alone top2.

Do you guys feel Martinez is remotely close to as great a mw as Hagler? Is Pac remotely close to as great as Duran? Is Khan,DLH,Corrales,Mosley,Hernandez REMOTELY close to as great as Tommy Hearns? No.. Not even close. Hell, are any of those close to as great as Benitez?

Ray Leonards resume completely ****s Floyds hypothetical (best case) resume. And hes a top10 atg.

Please, put things into perspective people. This is madness. Being called among the 20 best fighters of all time is FAR from an insult. It's quite extraordinary in fact, and a huuuuge accomplishment.


(and if some mental midget tells me Floyds greater because he didn't lose to Duran, I'm gonna throw up)