Whats your P4P list?

[IronDanHamza]

he did officially retire though. Remember the tearful retirement speech? was gone for two years? That's when Pac became #1. He came back, fought Marquez & Mosley, then left for 16 months (didn't retire). So imo he shouldn't be #1 technically on anyones list (just yet).

Now of course, it's another thing to say floyd is the best boxer in the game as of today, that's cool and most likely true, just sayin.

Yes. I remember his actual retirement.

Someone ranking him P4P at that point would be illogical considering he is in retirement.

But, when he came back in 2009, if someone wants to rank him #1 then that's on them. If they think he's the best then that's thier opinion. Which is all P4P is, an opinion.

He's not retired currently so he's eligable to rank so anyone who has Mayweather at #1 currently is because they think he's the best in the world.

[ИATAS]

Yes. I remember his actual retirement.

Someone ranking him P4P at that point would be illogical considering he is in retirement.

But, when he came back in 2009, if someone wants to rank him #1 then that's on them. If they think he's the best then that's thier opinion. Which is all P4P is, an opinion.

He's not retired currently so he's eligable to rank so anyone who has Mayweather at #1 currently is because they think he's the best in the world.

well of course it's all opinion, but it's still fun debating it

I mean I can have Gamboa #1 pound 4 pound and Rigondeax #5 and Kid Chocolate #10 but I would certainly hope someone would challenge my logic.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

well of course it's all opinion, but it's still fun debating it

I mean I can have Gamboa #1 pound 4 pound and Rigondeax #5 and Kid Chocolate #10 but I would certainly hope someone would challenge my logic.

dont you already have it like that? oh wait...its Nard at # 1, then Gamboa 2 right?

[AssasinKing]

If you aint got Pac, May, or Sergio in your top 3...

Your hating on something.

[THREAD-KILLER]

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather
3. Martinez
4. Marquez
5. W. Klitschko
6. Hopkins
7. Ward
8. Donaire
9. Bradley
10. Nishioka

Pretty low for Donaire considering your name. I'd have him top 5, easily.

[Gutz]

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. Donaire
4. Martinez
5. JMM
6. W. Klitcho
7. Ward
8. Khan
9. Cotto.
10. V klitcho

[ИATAS]

dont you already have it like that? oh wait...its Nard at # 1, then Gamboa 2 right?

Almost!

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. Nonito
4. Martinez
5. Hopkins
6. JMM
7. Ward
8. W. Klitschko
9. Wonjongkam
10. Froch/Khan/Gamboa I dunno

[Gutz]

If you aint got Pac, May, or Sergio in your top 3...

Your hating on something.

Top 4-5 is okay for Sergio..


Pac May .. top 2.. if anyone else. your hating..

[chiguy91]

1 - pacquiao
2 - mayweather
3 - martinez
4 - donaire
5 - hopkins
6 - ward
7 - marquez
8 - w. klitschko
9 - wonjonkam
10 - khan

[DrewWoodside]

No JMM? ....in your top 10? but I see Bradly,Froch,Vitali

and Cotto?!?

The only thing funnier than the opening post, was this first reply with the gif image. Awesome.