Who r ur top 5 greatest fighters all time p4p???

[Shogunofharlem1]

No order
1. Roberto Duran
2. Ray Robinson
3. Willie Pep
4. Henry Armstrong
5. Probably a three way between leonard, Hearns, whitaker, and depending on how I feel that particular day.

[sdcluser]

Hmm.....Larry Merchant or Charles Zelenoff?

I think Lahhrry would have kicked anyone's ass if he were 50 years younger.

<---running out of the thread.

[CubanGuyNYC]

No order
1. Roberto Duran
2. Ray Robinson
3. Willie Pep
4. Henry Armstrong
5. Probably a three way between leonard, Hearns, or whitaker.

Case in point: some personal choices! I wouldn't include any of these guys in an all-time five P4P list; but if I did, Ray Leonard would easily be my choice over Hearns and Whitaker.

[gatorDelux]

No order
1. Roberto Duran
2. Ray Robinson
3. Willie Pep
4. Henry Armstrong
5. Probably a three way between leonard, Hearns, whitaker, and depending on how I feel that particular day.

:3some::3some:

[Barry Halls]

anyone here have benny leonard in their top5?

[gatorDelux]

anyone here have benny leonard in their top5?

nah but top ten maybe

[Stray Dog]

mine

1 robinson
2 armstrong
3 pep
4 grebb
5 duran

but there are about 20 other guys that u could argue to be on a top 5 list

the only name that cant be moved IMO is robinson

I see what you did there.

personally, I wouldnt rank your beloved Duran over someone like Ali.

[gatorDelux]

I see what you did there.

personally, I wouldnt rank your beloved Duran over someone like Ali.

it could be argued that p4p duran was better.

duran and ali r def both top ten tho IMO


my list has changed before but robinson is always no 1 and the same guys r usualy in the top ten

[CubanGuyNYC]

it could be argued that p4p duran was better.

duran and ali r def both top ten tho IMO


my list has changed before but robinson is always no 1 and the same guys r usualy in the top ten

Of necessity, top five becomes slightly more opinionated. Top ten doesn't allow as much room for argument. As you stated, Duran is definitely a top ten P4P guy. But you can certainly argue that he doesn't make the top five (although I think he does).

[joelab75]

Duran
Leonard
Whitaker
Jones, Jr
Pacquiao